Lowik A J
Institute for Gender, Race, Sexuality and Social Justice, University of British Columbia, Vancouver, Canada.
Int J Transgend Health. 2021 Sep 25;22(1-2):113-125. doi: 10.1080/15532739.2020.1819507. eCollection 2021.
Critical menstruation studies is a field in its nascence, marginalized within the broader area of reproductive health research. Menstruation-related research is virtually absent from trans studies, itself a marginalized field of inquiry. This article focuses on the experiences of trans and non-binary menstruators, to contribute to this burgeoning area of study.
This article involves secondary data analysis of a qualitative dissertation research study on trans people's reproductive lives, health, and decision-making processes. Of the fourteen participants in the broader study, eleven discussed their perceptions of and experiences with menstruation and menstrual health. Those experiences where subjected to thematic narrative analysis, with a focus on themes that were substantively significant.
Participants describe experiences with amenorrhea associated with the use of testosterone, menstrual resumption following the cessation of testosterone and for other reasons, menstruation-related dysphoria management strategies beyond medical interventions, as well as barriers to menstruation-related health care. One participant describes bloodless periods as a trans woman, a phenomenon altogether absent from the clinical and experiential literature in this field. The article explores how cisnormativity, repronormativity and transnormativity informed the participants experiences of menstruation and reproductive health care.
Contributing novel stories to the literature, this article illustrates how clinically focused research fails to attend to the experiential components of menstruation for trans and non-binary people. Expanded knowledge is beneficial to the development of gender-inclusive menstruation research, clinical interventions, healthcare environments, and activist efforts.
批判性月经研究尚处于起步阶段,在更广泛的生殖健康研究领域中处于边缘地位。跨性别研究领域几乎没有与月经相关的研究,而跨性别研究本身也是一个处于边缘地位的研究领域。本文聚焦于跨性别者和非二元性别月经者的经历,为这一新兴研究领域做出贡献。
本文涉及对一项关于跨性别者生殖生活、健康和决策过程的定性论文研究的二次数据分析。在更广泛研究的14名参与者中,有11人讨论了他们对月经和月经健康的看法及经历。这些经历接受了主题叙事分析,重点关注具有实质意义的主题。
参与者描述了与使用睾酮相关的闭经经历、睾酮停用后及其他原因导致的月经恢复、非医疗干预之外的与月经相关的烦躁情绪管理策略,以及与月经相关的医疗保健障碍。一名参与者描述了作为跨性别女性的无血月经情况,这是该领域临床和经验文献中完全没有的现象。本文探讨了顺性别规范、生殖规范和跨性别规范如何影响参与者的月经和生殖健康护理经历。
本文为文献贡献了新颖的故事,说明了以临床为重点的研究如何未能关注跨性别者和非二元性别者月经的体验成分。扩展知识有利于发展性别包容的月经研究、临床干预、医疗环境和维权努力。