Lei Shaojuan, Zhang Xiaodong, Liu Suhui
School of Economics and Management, University of Science and Technology Beijing, Beijing 100083, China.
Entropy (Basel). 2021 Sep 21;23(9):1235. doi: 10.3390/e23091235.
A large amount of semantic content is generated during designer collaboration in open-source projects (OSPs). Based on the characteristics of knowledge collaboration behavior in OSPs, we constructed a directed, weighted, semantic-based knowledge collaborative network. Four social network analysis indexes were created to identify the key opinion leader nodes in the network using the entropy weight and TOPSIS method. Further, three degradation modes were designed for (1) the collaborative behavior of opinion leaders, (2) main knowledge dissemination behavior, and (3) main knowledge contribution behavior. Regarding the degradation model of the collaborative behavior of opinion leaders, we considered the propagation characteristics of opinion leaders to other nodes, and we created a susceptible-infected-removed (SIR) propagation model of the influence of opinion leaders' behaviors. Finally, based on empirical data from the Local Motors open-source vehicle design community, a dynamic robustness analysis experiment was carried out. The results showed that the robustness of our constructed network varied for different degradation modes: the degradation of the opinion leaders' collaborative behavior had the lowest robustness; this was followed by the main knowledge dissemination behavior and the main knowledge contribution behavior; the degradation of random behavior had the highest robustness. Our method revealed the influence of the degradation of collaborative behavior of different types of nodes on the robustness of the network. This could be used to formulate the management strategy of the open-source design community, thus promoting the stable development of OSPs.
在开源项目(OSP)的设计师协作过程中会产生大量语义内容。基于开源项目中知识协作行为的特征,我们构建了一个基于语义的有向加权知识协作网络。利用熵权法和TOPSIS法创建了四个社会网络分析指标,以识别网络中的关键意见领袖节点。此外,针对(1)意见领袖的协作行为、(2)主要知识传播行为和(3)主要知识贡献行为设计了三种退化模式。对于意见领袖协作行为的退化模型,我们考虑了意见领袖对其他节点的传播特性,并创建了意见领袖行为影响的易感-感染-移除(SIR)传播模型。最后,基于Local Motors开源汽车设计社区的实证数据进行了动态鲁棒性分析实验。结果表明,对于不同的退化模式,我们构建的网络的鲁棒性各不相同:意见领袖协作行为的退化鲁棒性最低;其次是主要知识传播行为和主要知识贡献行为;随机行为的退化鲁棒性最高。我们的方法揭示了不同类型节点协作行为的退化对网络鲁棒性的影响。这可用于制定开源设计社区的管理策略,从而促进开源项目的稳定发展。