Zur Bruegge Talke F, Liese Andrea, Donath Sören, Kalies Stefan, Kosanke Maike, Dittrich-Breiholz Oliver, Czech Sandra, Bauer Verena N, Bleich André, Buettner Manuela
Institute for Laboratory Animal Science, Hannover Medical School, Hannover, Germany.
Institute of Quantum Optics, Leibniz University Hannover, Hannover, Germany.
Stem Cells Int. 2021 Sep 17;2021:9041423. doi: 10.1155/2021/9041423. eCollection 2021.
In recent years, stem cell-derived organoids have become a cell culture standard that is widely used for studying various scientific issues that were previously investigated through animal experiments and using common tumor cell lines. After their initial hype, concerns regarding their standardization have been raised. Here, we aim to provide some insights into our experience in standardizing murine colonic epithelial organoids, which we use as a replacement method for research on inflammatory bowel disease. Considering good scientific practice, we examined various factors that might challenge the design and outcome of experiments using these organoids. First, to analyze the impact of antibiotics/antimycotics, we performed kinetic experiments using ZellShield® and measured the gene expression levels of the tight junction markers , , and , the proliferation marker , and the proinflammatory cytokine . Because we found no differences between cultivations with and without ZellShield®, we then performed infection experiments using the probiotic Nissle 1917 as an already established model setup to analyze the impact of technical, interexperimental, and biologic replicates. We demonstrate that interexperimental differences pose the greatest challenge for reproducibility and explain our strategies for addressing these differences. Additionally, we conducted infection experiments using freshly isolated and cryopreserved/thawed organoids and found that cryopreservation influenced the experimental outcome during early passages. Formerly cryopreserved colonoids exhibited a premature appearance and a higher proinflammatory response to bacterial stimulation. Therefore, we recommend analyzing the growth characteristics and reliability of cryopreserved organoids before to their use in experiments together with conducting several independent experiments under standardized conditions. Taken together, our findings demonstrate that organoid culture, if standardized, constitutes a good tool for reducing the need for animal experiments and might further improve our understanding of, for example, the role of epithelial cells in inflammatory bowel disease development.
近年来,干细胞来源的类器官已成为一种细胞培养标准,广泛用于研究各种科学问题,这些问题以前是通过动物实验和使用常见肿瘤细胞系来研究的。在经历了最初的炒作之后,人们对其标准化提出了担忧。在此,我们旨在分享一些关于标准化小鼠结肠上皮类器官的经验见解,我们将其用作炎症性肠病研究的替代方法。考虑到良好的科学实践,我们研究了可能对使用这些类器官的实验设计和结果构成挑战的各种因素。首先,为了分析抗生素/抗真菌剂的影响,我们使用ZellShield®进行了动力学实验,并测量了紧密连接标志物、、和、增殖标志物以及促炎细胞因子的基因表达水平。由于我们发现在使用和不使用ZellShield®的培养之间没有差异,然后我们使用益生菌Nissle 1917作为已建立的模型设置进行感染实验,以分析技术、实验间和生物学重复的影响。我们证明实验间差异对可重复性构成了最大挑战,并解释了我们应对这些差异的策略。此外,我们使用新鲜分离的和冷冻保存/解冻的类器官进行了感染实验,发现冷冻保存在早期传代过程中影响了实验结果。以前冷冻保存的结肠类器官表现出过早的外观以及对细菌刺激的更高促炎反应。因此,我们建议在将冷冻保存的类器官用于实验之前分析其生长特性和可靠性,并在标准化条件下进行几个独立实验。综上所述,我们的研究结果表明,如果标准化,类器官培养是减少动物实验需求的良好工具,并且可能进一步增进我们对例如上皮细胞在炎症性肠病发展中的作用的理解。