Orygen, Parkville, Victoria, Australia.
Centre for Youth Mental Health, The University of Melbourne, Melbourne, Victoria, Australia.
J Clin Psychol. 2021 Dec;77(12):2781-2797. doi: 10.1002/jclp.23257. Epub 2021 Oct 2.
Emerging research highlights that therapists experience difficulty engaging and retaining male clients in talk therapy. Understanding therapists' challenges when working with men can inform gender-specific training efforts.
Open-ended qualitative survey data were collected from a sample of 421 Australian-based therapists. Participants described that which they find most challenging about therapeutic work with men. Responses were analyzed using inductive thematic analysis.
Three themes were revealed: (1) men's wavering commitment and engagement; (2) males as ill-equipped for therapy; and (3) therapists' uncertainty. Contrasting state and trait constructs, much of the men's state-based wavering commitment and engagement was positioned as amenable to change whereas traits assigned men as ill-equipped for therapy and unreachable.
These findings underscore a clear need to better target training efforts to directly respond to the needs of therapists working with men, such that all therapists are well-equipped to meet men with gender-sensitive therapy.
新出现的研究强调,治疗师在与男性客户进行谈话治疗时遇到了困难,难以吸引并留住他们。了解治疗师在与男性合作时所面临的挑战,可以为针对性别的培训工作提供信息。
从 421 名澳大利亚治疗师组成的样本中收集了开放式定性调查数据。参与者描述了他们在与男性进行治疗工作时最具挑战性的方面。使用归纳主题分析对回复进行了分析。
揭示了三个主题:(1)男性犹豫不决的承诺和参与度;(2)男性不适合接受治疗;(3)治疗师的不确定性。与状态和特质结构形成对比的是,男性的大部分基于状态的犹豫不决的承诺和参与度被认为是可以改变的,而特质则将男性描述为不适合接受治疗且难以企及。
这些发现强调了明确的培训需求,以直接针对与男性合作的治疗师的需求做出回应,从而使所有治疗师都能够为男性提供敏感性别问题的治疗。