School Of Health Sciences, Wuhan University, Located on No. 115 Donghu Road, Wuhan, Hubei province 430071, China.
Nurse Educ Today. 2022 Jan;108:105126. doi: 10.1016/j.nedt.2021.105126. Epub 2021 Sep 4.
Nursing education faces daunting challenges in preparing graduates to think critically in the context of the complex healthcare system of practice. Concept-based teaching (CBT) is an effective approach used in curriculum reform to cultivate critical thinking and active learning abilities in nursing students.
This research aims to investigate faculty's experiences while developing and implementing CBT, and clarify barriers to and facilitators of CBT reform in China.
A descriptive qualitative study.
A university in middle China.
Full-time teachers teaching in a four-year undergraduate nursing program that offers CBT.
This study used a purposive sampling method and collected data through semi-structured interviews. The researchers digitally recorded and transcribed each interview verbatim. The conventional content analysis method was used to examine the faculty's experiences while developing and implementing CBT. Theoretical saturation was achieved using ten educators due to the group's high homogeneity.
Through the data analysis process, five themes emerged from the participants' descriptions: questioning themselves, taking responsibility, struggling with conflict and stress, recognizing support, and feeling worthwhile. Thirteen subthemes were also identified. The overarching themes extracted from the participants' experiences were struggling with conflict and stress and feeling worthwhile.
The faculty's CBT experiences ranged from curiosity and expectation at the initial stage to confusion in the face of challenges at the middle stage. The faculty ultimately believed that their time and energy were well-invested. Faculty faced significant challenges due to students' resistance, peer maladjustment, and inner conflict during the reform process, but the administrators supported their transition and helped them overcome difficulties through change theory-based workshop training. Developing effective strategies was indispensable to reduce both faculty's and students' resistance and negative reactions.
护理教育在培养毕业生在复杂的医疗保健实践体系中进行批判性思维方面面临着艰巨的挑战。基于概念的教学(CBT)是课程改革中用于培养护理学生批判性思维和主动学习能力的有效方法。
本研究旨在调查教师在开发和实施 CBT 时的经验,并阐明在中国 CBT 改革的障碍和促进因素。
描述性定性研究。
中国中部的一所大学。
在提供 CBT 的四年制本科护理课程中全职授课的教师。
本研究采用目的抽样法,通过半结构化访谈收集数据。研究人员将每次访谈逐字记录并转录为数字形式。采用常规内容分析法,检查教师在开发和实施 CBT 时的经验。由于组内高度同质,使用十名教育者达到了理论饱和度。
通过数据分析过程,从参与者的描述中出现了五个主题:自我质疑、承担责任、在冲突和压力中挣扎、认识到支持和感到有价值。还确定了十三个子主题。从参与者的经验中提取的总体主题是在冲突和压力中挣扎和感到有价值。
教师的 CBT 经验从最初阶段的好奇和期待到面对挑战时的困惑。教师最终认为他们的时间和精力投入得很值。教师在改革过程中因学生的抵制、同伴不适应和内心冲突而面临重大挑战,但管理人员通过基于变革理论的工作坊培训支持他们的过渡并帮助他们克服困难。制定有效的策略对于减少教师和学生的抵制和负面反应是必不可少的。