Lattal Kennon A
Department of Psychology, West Virginia University, Morgantown, WV 26506-6040 USA.
Perspect Behav Sci. 2021 Jun 30;44(2-3):473-481. doi: 10.1007/s40614-021-00300-3. eCollection 2021 Sep.
B. F. Skinner's 1976 editorial "Farewell my LOVELY," eulogizing the passing of the cumulative record as a primary form of data analysis, borrowed its title from a 1936 E. B. White essay of the same name. In it, White, a well-known 20 century essayist and children's book author, eulogized the Model T Ford. This article considers the parallels between the machine behind the cumulative record-the cumulative recorder-and White's Model T. The cumulative recorder considered for comparison is the Ralph Gerbrands Company Model C-3, widely considered by scientists of the time to be the best of the cumulative recorders that proliferated between the 1950s and the 1990s. On a much more modest scale, the C-3 became as popular, visible, distinct, and important in research laboratories devoted, but not limited, to the experimental analysis of behavior as was the Model T on the roads of early 20 century America. Not only were there parallels in manufacture and marketing, but, more importantly, in reliability, durability and ease of function of these two machines that changed the respective practices and culture of behavioral psychology and the world.
B. F. 斯金纳1976年的社论《别了,我的挚爱》悼念了作为一种主要数据分析形式的累积记录的消逝,其标题借用了1936年E. B. 怀特的一篇同名文章。在那篇文章中,怀特这位20世纪著名的散文家和儿童书作者悼念了T型福特汽车。本文探讨了累积记录背后的机器——累积记录器——与怀特的T型福特汽车之间的相似之处。用于比较的累积记录器是拉尔夫·格布兰德公司的C - 3型,当时的科学家普遍认为它是20世纪50年代至90年代间大量涌现的累积记录器中最好的一款。规模虽小得多,但C - 3型在专门(但不限于)从事行为实验分析的研究实验室里,变得像20世纪初美国道路上的T型福特汽车一样受欢迎、显眼、独特且重要。这两款机器不仅在制造和营销方面有相似之处,更重要的是,在可靠性、耐用性和功能易用性方面也有相似之处,它们改变了行为心理学和整个世界各自的实践与文化。