Luke Natural Resources Institute Finland - Economics and society, Latokartanonkaari 9, FI-00790, Helsinki, Finland.
Environ Manage. 2022 Jan;69(1):154-168. doi: 10.1007/s00267-021-01543-1. Epub 2021 Oct 14.
Drained agricultural peatlands emit significantly higher amounts of greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions per hectare than mineral soils. GHG abatement costs for representative cereals (CF) and dairy (DF) farms in southwestern Finland were estimated by integrating an emission-based tax together with an option to invest in a subsidized adjustable drainage system on peat soils in a farm-level dynamic optimization model. With an average 10% share of peat soils from overall farm area, emissions tax rates over 15 (CF) and 19 (DF) €/tCOe triggered adjustable drainage investments with a significant reduction in GHG emissions per ha, when assuming no crop-yield effect from the adjustable drainage. Abatement costs for emissions tax rates €12-50/tCOe/ha were €16-44/tCOe (CF) and €26-51/tCOe (DF) for whole farm-soil emissions, depending on the share of peatlands on the farm, on the yield effects of adjustable drainage, and on crop prices. High emissions tax rates imply higher abatement costs since farms have a limited capability to adjust their production and land use. Thus, emissions reductions from peatlands can be achieved at reasonable costs when investing in adjustable drainage on peatlands. The income losses due to emissions tax, however, are high, but they can be compensated for farmers by lumpsum payments independent of their production decisions. Since existing agricultural policies such as the EU CAP system may have limited effectiveness on GHG emissions, the emissions tax and adjustable drainage on peatlands could promote GHG abatement significantly on farms and areas with abundant peatlands.
排水后的农用泥炭地每公顷温室气体(GHG)排放量比矿物质土壤高得多。通过在农场层面的动态优化模型中整合基于排放的税收,并为泥炭地的补贴可调排水系统投资提供选择,估算了芬兰西南部具有代表性的谷物(CF)和奶牛(DF)农场的温室气体减排成本。假设可调排水对作物产量没有影响,在整个农场面积中平均有 10%的泥炭地,当排放税率超过 15(CF)和 19(DF)欧元/吨二氧化碳当量时,可调排水投资将触发,从而显著减少每公顷的 GHG 排放量。对于 12-50 欧元/吨二氧化碳当量/公顷的排放税率,整个农场土壤排放的减排成本为 16-44 欧元/吨二氧化碳当量(CF)和 26-51 欧元/吨二氧化碳当量(DF),具体取决于农场中泥炭地的比例、可调排水的产量效应以及作物价格。排放税率较高意味着减排成本较高,因为农场调整生产和土地利用的能力有限。因此,通过在泥炭地上投资可调排水,可以以合理的成本实现泥炭地的减排。然而,由于排放税导致的收入损失很高,但农民可以通过与生产决策无关的一次性付款得到补偿。由于现有的农业政策(如欧盟 CAP 系统)可能对温室气体排放的效果有限,因此排放税和泥炭地的可调排水可以显著促进农场和泥炭地丰富地区的温室气体减排。