Department of Community Medicine, University of Nigeria Teaching Hospital, Enugu, Nigeria.
Institute of Public Health University of Nigeria, Enugu, Nigeria.
BMC Public Health. 2021 Oct 15;21(1):1863. doi: 10.1186/s12889-021-11942-y.
Conflicting schedules and geographic access limit prospects for mutually beneficial relationships between experts and early career professionals. A formal long-distance mentorship program could address these barriers and potentially bridge the gap of traditional face-to-face mentorship. This study was done to determine the feasibility of implementing a formal long-distance mentorship program amongst public health physicians of Nigeria.
A mixed-method study comprising of in-depth interviews and surveys was used to collect information from members of the Association of Public Health Physicians in Nigeria. A total of 134 survey participants were recruited consecutively during an annual scientific meeting of the association. In-depth interviewees were purposively selected to ensure diversity in expertise, experience, and social stratifiers such as age. Quantitative data were analyzed using descriptive and inferential statistics, while qualitative data were analyzed using thematic content analysis.
Public health physicians of Nigeria are willing to participate in a formal Long-Distance Mentorship Program, and four elements of feasibility were highlighted as necessary for implementing the program. Namely i) capacity to coordinate LDMP, ii) technical expertise and individual competence to provide mentorship, iii) financial capacity to implement and sustain LDMP, and iv) demand for mentorship by mentees. There is a consensus that the organizational structure of the National Postgraduate Medical College of Nigeria and West African College of Physicians provide an enabling environment to initiate a LDMP for public health physicians of Nigeria. The vast human resources with various expertise and the annual National conferences can be leveraged upon to champion and administer the program. However, there is a need for an administrative structure and technical expertise to enable proper coordination. More so, the need for demand creation and the financial requirement was considered gaps that need to be filled to be able to ensure feasibility. Bivariate analysis showed a significant relationship between the dependent variable (preferred role- mentor/mentee) and independent variables (age, year of graduation, and the number of years of practice), while the binary logistic regression model showed that physicians are more likely to participate as mentors with each unit increase in the number of years of practice. This further buttressed the need to commence the mentoring process as soon as trainees gain entrance into the program, as mentorship does not just prepare them for excellent public health practice, but also builds their capacity to mentor the younger and upcoming public health physicians.
There are enabling structures to incorporate a formal long-distance mentorship program for public health physicians in Nigeria, and physicians are willing to participate in such a program. However, the feasibility of establishing a successful and sustainable program will require robust coordination, technical expertise, demand creation, and financial commitment at both institutional and college levels.
专家和初级职业人员之间互利关系受到日程冲突和地域限制的阻碍。正式的远程指导计划可以解决这些障碍,并有可能弥补传统面对面指导的差距。本研究旨在确定在尼日利亚公共卫生医师中实施正式远程指导计划的可行性。
采用混合方法研究,包括深入访谈和调查,从尼日利亚公共卫生医师协会成员那里收集信息。在协会的年度科学会议上连续招募了 134 名调查参与者。深入访谈者是根据专业知识、经验和社会分层(如年龄)的多样性有目的地选择的。定量数据采用描述性和推断性统计进行分析,定性数据采用主题内容分析进行分析。
尼日利亚的公共卫生医师愿意参加正式的远程指导计划,并强调了实施该计划的四个可行性要素。即:i)协调 LDMP 的能力,ii)提供指导的技术专长和个人能力,iii)实施和维持 LDMP 的财务能力,iv)学员对指导的需求。人们一致认为,尼日利亚国家研究生医学院和西非医师学院的组织结构为启动尼日利亚公共卫生医师的远程指导计划提供了有利环境。拥有各种专业知识的庞大人力资源和年度国家会议可以利用起来支持和管理该计划。然而,需要建立行政结构和技术专长,以实现妥善协调。此外,需要创造需求并提供资金,以确保可行性。单变量分析显示,因变量(首选角色——导师/学员)与自变量(年龄、毕业年份和实践年限)之间存在显著关系,而二元逻辑回归模型显示,随着实践年限每增加一个单位,医师更有可能作为导师参与。这进一步证明了需要尽快在学员进入该计划时开始指导过程,因为指导不仅使他们为优秀的公共卫生实践做好准备,而且还培养他们指导年轻的即将到来的公共卫生医师的能力。
尼日利亚有实施正式远程指导计划的有利结构,医师愿意参加此类计划。然而,建立一个成功和可持续的计划的可行性将需要在机构和学院层面进行强有力的协调、技术专长、需求创造和财务承诺。