van Osta Nick, Kirkels Feddo P, van Loon Tim, Koopsen Tijmen, Lyon Aurore, Meiburg Roel, Huberts Wouter, Cramer Maarten J, Delhaas Tammo, Haugaa Kristina H, Teske Arco J, Lumens Joost
Department of Biomedical Engineering, Cardiovascular Research Institute Maastricht, Maastricht University, Maastricht, Netherlands.
Division Heart and Lungs, Department of Cardiology, University Medical Center Utrecht, Utrecht, Netherlands.
Front Physiol. 2021 Sep 30;12:738926. doi: 10.3389/fphys.2021.738926. eCollection 2021.
Computational models of the cardiovascular system are widely used to simulate cardiac (dys)function. Personalization of such models for patient-specific simulation of cardiac function remains challenging. Measurement uncertainty affects accuracy of parameter estimations. In this study, we present a methodology for patient-specific estimation and uncertainty quantification of parameters in the closed-loop CircAdapt model of the human heart and circulation using echocardiographic deformation imaging. Based on patient-specific estimated parameters we aim to reveal the mechanical substrate underlying deformation abnormalities in patients with arrhythmogenic cardiomyopathy (AC). We used adaptive multiple importance sampling to estimate the posterior distribution of regional myocardial tissue properties. This methodology is implemented in the CircAdapt cardiovascular modeling platform and applied to estimate active and passive tissue properties underlying regional deformation patterns, left ventricular volumes, and right ventricular diameter. First, we tested the accuracy of this method and its inter- and intraobserver variability using nine datasets obtained in AC patients. Second, we tested the trueness of the estimation using nine generated virtual patient datasets representative for various stages of AC. Finally, we applied this method to two longitudinal series of echocardiograms of two pathogenic mutation carriers without established myocardial disease at baseline. Tissue characteristics of virtual patients were accurately estimated with a highest density interval containing the true parameter value of 9% (95% CI [0-79]). Variances of estimated posterior distributions in patient data and virtual data were comparable, supporting the reliability of the patient estimations. Estimations were highly reproducible with an overlap in posterior distributions of 89.9% (95% CI [60.1-95.9]). Clinically measured deformation, ejection fraction, and end-diastolic volume were accurately simulated. In presence of worsening of deformation over time, estimated tissue properties also revealed functional deterioration. This method facilitates patient-specific simulation-based estimation of regional ventricular tissue properties from non-invasive imaging data, taking into account both measurement and model uncertainties. Two proof-of-principle case studies suggested that this cardiac digital twin technology enables quantitative monitoring of AC disease progression in early stages of disease.
心血管系统的计算模型被广泛用于模拟心脏(功能)异常。针对患者特异性的心脏功能模拟对这类模型进行个性化定制仍然具有挑战性。测量不确定性会影响参数估计的准确性。在本研究中,我们提出了一种方法,用于使用超声心动图变形成像对人体心脏和循环的闭环CircAdapt模型中的参数进行患者特异性估计和不确定性量化。基于患者特异性估计参数,我们旨在揭示致心律失常性心肌病(AC)患者变形异常背后的力学基础。我们使用自适应多重重要性采样来估计区域心肌组织特性的后验分布。该方法在CircAdapt心血管建模平台中实现,并用于估计区域变形模式、左心室容积和右心室直径背后的主动和被动组织特性。首先,我们使用在AC患者中获得的九个数据集测试了该方法的准确性及其观察者间和观察者内的变异性。其次,我们使用九个代表AC不同阶段的生成虚拟患者数据集测试了估计的真实性。最后,我们将该方法应用于两名基线时无确诊心肌病的致病突变携带者的两个纵向超声心动图系列。虚拟患者的组织特征被准确估计,最高密度区间包含真实参数值的比例为9%(95%置信区间[0 - 79])。患者数据和虚拟数据中估计后验分布的方差具有可比性,支持了患者估计的可靠性。估计具有高度可重复性,后验分布的重叠率为89.9%(95%置信区间[60.1 - 95.9])。临床测量的变形、射血分数和舒张末期容积得到了准确模拟。随着时间推移变形恶化时,估计的组织特性也显示出功能恶化。该方法有助于从无创成像数据中基于患者特异性模拟估计区域心室组织特性,同时考虑测量和模型不确定性。两个原理验证案例研究表明,这种心脏数字孪生技术能够在疾病早期对AC疾病进展进行定量监测。