Institute of Psychology and Behavioral Science, Shanghai Jiao Tong University, Shanghai, China.
Shanghai Key Laboratory of Psychotic Disorder, Shanghai Mental Health Center, Shanghai Jiao Tong University School of Medicine, Shanghai, China.
Transl Vis Sci Technol. 2021 Oct 4;10(12):22. doi: 10.1167/tvst.10.12.22.
Retinal implants (RIs) provide new vision for patients suffering from photoreceptor degeneration in the retina. The limited vision gained by RI, however, leaves room for improvement by training regimes.
Two groups of normal-sighted participants were respectively trained with videos or still images of daily objects in a labeling task. Object appearance was simulated to resemble RI perception. In Experiment 1, the training effect was measured as the change in performance during the training, and the same labeling task was conducted after 1 week to test the retention. In Experiment 2 with a different pool of participants, a reverse labeling task was included before (pre-test) and after the training (post-test) to show if the training effect could be generalized into a different task context.
Both groups showed improved object recognition through training that was maintained for a week, and the video group showed better improvement (Experiment 1). Both groups showed improved object recognition in a different task that was maintained for a week, but the video group did not show better retention than the image group (Experiment 2).
Training with video materials leads to more improvement than training with still images in simulated RI perception, but this better improvement was specific to the trained task.
We recommend videos as better training materials than still images for patients with RIs to improve object recognition when the task-goal is highly specific. We also propose here that achieving highly specific training goals runs the risk of limiting the generalization of the training effects.
视网膜植入物 (RIs) 为视网膜光感受器变性的患者提供了新的视力。然而,由于 RI 获得的视力有限,通过训练方案仍有改进的空间。
两组视力正常的参与者分别在标记任务中接受日常物体的视频或静态图像训练。物体的外观被模拟为类似于 RI 感知。在实验 1 中,训练效果通过训练过程中的性能变化来衡量,并且在 1 周后进行相同的标记任务以测试保留。在实验 2 中,参与者的不同群体中,包括在训练之前(预测试)和之后(后测试)的反向标记任务,以显示训练效果是否可以推广到不同的任务环境。
两组参与者在训练后物体识别能力均得到提高,且持续一周,视频组的提高更为显著(实验 1)。两组参与者在不同任务中的物体识别能力均得到提高,且持续一周,但视频组的保留效果并不优于图像组(实验 2)。
与使用静态图像相比,使用视频材料进行训练在模拟 RI 感知中会导致更多的提高,但这种更好的提高仅限于受过训练的任务。
我们建议在任务目标高度特定的情况下,为 RIs 患者提供视频作为更好的训练材料,以提高物体识别能力。我们还建议,实现高度特定的训练目标可能会限制训练效果的推广。