Department of Health Systems Management, School of Health Sciences, Ariel University, Ariel, Israel.
Smokler Center for Health Policy Research, Myers-JDC-Brookdale Institute, Jerusalem, Israel.
Isr J Health Policy Res. 2021 Oct 18;10(1):56. doi: 10.1186/s13584-021-00492-8.
Developmental-behavioral issues are among the most frequent and disabling conditions of children and adolescents seen in ambulatory settings. Guidelines of the Israeli Pediatric Association and the Israeli Society for Developmental Pediatrics specify the role of the primary-care pediatrician in screening and early identification of mild developmental behavioral conditions and define the criteria for referral to child development institutes. The aims of this study were to examine and describe how directors of these institutes perceive the role and involvement of community pediatricians in child development.
Qualitative interviews of the directors of 22 child development institutes from the ministry of health and the four health plans.
According to the interviewees, there is little involvement of community pediatricians in detecting developmental delays, and it is mainly nurses and preschool teachers who detect such delays. They report that the key barriers that deter community pediatricians from greater involvement in child development diagnosis and treatment are lack of time, lack of compensation, and insufficient clinical knowledge. The interviewees would like to see community pediatricians conducting the primary medical evaluation, providing parental guidance, referring to therapists in mild cases, exercising discretion before referring children to child development institutes and providing relevant information to the institutes in the referral process. The mechanisms that they proposed for increasing the involvement of community pediatricians were expansion of pediatricians' training, increased pediatricians' use of teleconsultation with child development specialists and incentives for thorough performance of developmental assessments.
Due to the importance of the Issue, we strongly recommend that policymakers require child development principles, evaluation, and providing appropriate parental guidance in the curriculum of the Israeli pediatric residency program. In addition, health plans should compensate pediatricians who need to conduct longer visits for children with developmental delays. The health plans should also develop teleconsultation channels for pediatricians with child development specialists to reduce unnecessary referrals to child development institutes.
发育行为问题是在门诊环境中最常见和最致残的儿童和青少年疾病之一。以色列儿科协会和以色列发育儿科协会的指南规定了初级保健儿科医生在筛查和早期识别轻度发育行为疾病方面的作用,并定义了向儿童发育研究所转介的标准。本研究的目的是检查和描述这些研究所的主任如何看待社区儿科医生在儿童发育方面的作用和参与。
对来自卫生部和四个健康计划的 22 家儿童发育研究所的所长进行了定性访谈。
根据受访者的说法,社区儿科医生在发现发育迟缓方面的参与度很低,主要是护士和学前教师发现了这种迟缓。他们报告说,阻止社区儿科医生更多地参与儿童发育诊断和治疗的主要障碍是缺乏时间、缺乏补偿和临床知识不足。受访者希望看到社区儿科医生进行初步的医学评估,为家长提供指导,在轻度病例中向治疗师转介,在向儿童发育研究所转介之前谨慎行事,并在转介过程中向研究所提供相关信息。他们提出的增加社区儿科医生参与的机制包括扩大儿科医生的培训、增加儿科医生与发育专家的远程咨询使用以及激励他们全面进行发育评估。
鉴于这一问题的重要性,我们强烈建议政策制定者要求儿童发育原则、评估和适当的父母指导纳入以色列儿科住院医师培训课程。此外,健康计划应补偿需要为发育迟缓儿童进行更长时间就诊的儿科医生。健康计划还应开发儿科医生与发育专家的远程咨询渠道,以减少向儿童发育研究所的不必要转介。