Department of Epidemiology and Biostatistics, Dornsife School of Public Health, Drexel University, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania.
Direction de la Protection de la Santé de la Population, Ministère de la Santé, Ouagadougou, Burkina Faso.
Am J Trop Med Hyg. 2021 Oct 25;106(1):268-274. doi: 10.4269/ajtmh.21-0817.
Coverage surveys for mass drug administration (MDA) rely on respondent recall and often permit proxy responses, whereby another household member is allowed to respond on behalf of an absent individual. In this secondary analysis of coverage surveys in Malawi, Burkina Faso, and Uganda, we explore the characteristics of individuals who require proxy responses and quantify the association between proxy responses and reported drug coverage. The adjusted logistic regression model found that men 11-39 years and women 11-18 years who were eligible for MDA had greater odds of requiring a proxy response compared with ineligible men and women in the same age groups. A hierarchical multivariable analysis found that proxy responses had 1.70 times the odds of reporting ingestion of MDA drugs compared with first-person responses, controlling for age and sex (95% CI: 1.17, 2.46). This finding is surprising, given that individuals absent during a coverage survey may also have been absent during the MDA, and suggests that proxy responses may be leading to an inflation of survey estimates of drug coverage. This study highlights the possibility for recall bias in proxy responses to MDA coverage; however, excluding absent individuals from coverage surveys would introduce a new bias. Further research is necessary to determine the best method for obtaining information on drug coverage when individuals are absent.
大规模药物治疗(MDA)的覆盖率调查依赖于受访者的回忆,并且通常允许代理回复,即允许另一名家庭成员代表缺席的个人做出回应。在马拉维、布基纳法索和乌干达的覆盖率调查的二次分析中,我们探讨了需要代理回复的个人的特征,并量化了代理回复与报告药物覆盖率之间的关联。调整后的逻辑回归模型发现,与同年龄段不符合 MDA 条件的男性和女性相比,11-39 岁的男性和 11-18 岁的女性有更大的可能性需要代理回复。分层多变量分析发现,在控制年龄和性别后,与第一人称回复相比,代理回复报告服用 MDA 药物的可能性高出 1.70 倍(95%CI:1.17,2.46)。这一发现令人惊讶,因为在覆盖率调查期间缺席的个人也可能在 MDA 期间缺席,这表明代理回复可能导致调查估计的药物覆盖率膨胀。本研究强调了 MDA 覆盖率代理回复中可能存在回忆偏差的可能性;然而,将缺席者排除在覆盖率调查之外将引入新的偏差。当个人缺席时,需要进一步研究以确定获取药物覆盖率信息的最佳方法。