Waqas Ahmed, Mehmood Shariq, Jawwad Arwah Muhammad, Pittam Bradley, Kundu Shantanu, Correia Jorge César, AlMughamis Nouf
Institute of Population Health, University of Liverpool, Liverpool, United Kingdom.
Lahore General Hospital, Lahore, Pakistan.
Front Digit Health. 2021 Jan 25;2:610837. doi: 10.3389/fdgth.2020.610837. eCollection 2020.
The progress and innovation in telemedicine within the Middle Eastern countries have not been heavily monitored. Therefore, the present study aims to analyze the scholarly work conducted in the Arab world, using reproducible statistical and scientometric techniques. An electronic search of Web of Science (core database) had been conducted through use of an extensive search strategy comprising of keywords specific to the Arab region, EMRO countries, telehealth, medical conditions, and disorders. A total yield of 1,630 search results were processed, indexed through July 7, 2020. CiteSpace (5.7.R1, Drexel University, Pennsylvania, USA) is a Java-based application, a user-friendly tool for conducting scientometric analyses. The present analyses found a lack of innovation in the field of digital health in the Arab countries. Many gaps in research were found in Arab countries, which will be discussed subsequently. Digital health research was clustered around themes of big data and artificial intelligence; a lack of progress was seen in telemedicine and digital health. Furthermore, only a small proportion of these publications had principal or corresponding authors from Arab countries. A clear disparity in digital health research in the Arab world was evident after comparing these insights with our previous investigation on telemedicine research in the global context. Telemedicine research is still in its infancy in the Middle Eastern countries. Recommendations include diversification of the research landscape and interdisciplinary collaborations in this area.
中东国家远程医疗的进展和创新尚未得到严格监测。因此,本研究旨在运用可重复的统计和科学计量技术,分析阿拉伯世界开展的学术工作。通过使用包含特定于阿拉伯地区、东地中海区域办事处国家、远程医疗、医疗状况和疾病的关键词的广泛搜索策略,对科学网(核心数据库)进行了电子搜索。共处理了1630条搜索结果,并将其索引至2020年7月7日。CiteSpace(5.7.R1,美国宾夕法尼亚州德雷塞尔大学)是一个基于Java的应用程序,是进行科学计量分析的用户友好工具。目前的分析发现阿拉伯国家在数字健康领域缺乏创新。在阿拉伯国家发现了许多研究空白,随后将进行讨论。数字健康研究集中在大数据和人工智能主题上;远程医疗和数字健康方面进展不足。此外,这些出版物中只有一小部分的主要作者或通讯作者来自阿拉伯国家。将这些见解与我们之前在全球背景下对远程医疗研究的调查进行比较后,阿拉伯世界在数字健康研究方面的明显差距显而易见。中东国家的远程医疗研究仍处于起步阶段。建议包括使该领域的研究格局多样化以及开展跨学科合作。