Medical Program, Weill Cornell Medicine Qatar, Doha, State of Qatar.
J Telemed Telecare. 2017 May;23(4):452-459. doi: 10.1177/1357633X16647894. Epub 2016 May 28.
Introduction The Gulf Cooperation Council (GCC or 'Arabian Gulf'), comprising Bahrain, Kuwait, Oman, Qatar, Saudi Arabia and United Arab Emirates, is a political organization sharing a common history and culture. All GCC nations have made substantial investments in telecommunications and electronic health infrastructure since 2000. Methods We conducted a literature search in English and Arabic on peer-reviewed e-health research up to December 2014 originating in the GCC. The objective was to retrieve all research on e-health in the GCC and to categorize and analyse it qualitatively to reveal the current state of e-health research and development in the region. Inclusion criteria included peer-reviewed articles, books, book chapters, conference papers and graduate theses written on e-health in the GCC. Blogs, health websites and non-peer-reviewed literature were excluded. Results Three hundred and six articles were retrieved, categorized and analysed qualitatively to reveal the state of e-health research in the GCC. Both country-specific and GCC-wide major themes were identified using NVivo 10.0 qualitative software and summarized. The most common type of study was an overview (35.0%), with common study designs of case studies (26.8%) and descriptive articles (46.4%). Significant themes were: prospective national benefits from e-health, implementation and satisfaction with electronic health records, online technologies in medical education, innovative systems (case studies), and information security and personal health information. Discussion This is the first comprehensive analytical literature review of e-health in the GCC. Important research gaps were identified: few cost-benefit analyses, controlled interventional studies, or research targeting gender and religious issues were retrieved.
简介
海湾合作委员会(GCC 或“阿拉伯湾”)由巴林、科威特、阿曼、卡塔尔、沙特阿拉伯和阿拉伯联合酋长国组成,是一个拥有共同历史和文化的政治组织。自 2000 年以来,所有 GCC 国家都在电信和电子卫生基础设施方面进行了大量投资。
方法
我们对截至 2014 年 12 月源自 GCC 的同行评议电子卫生研究进行了英文和阿拉伯文文献检索。目的是检索所有关于 GCC 电子卫生的研究,并对其进行分类和定性分析,以揭示该地区电子卫生研究和开发的现状。纳入标准包括关于 GCC 电子卫生的同行评议文章、书籍、书籍章节、会议论文和研究生论文。博客、卫生网站和非同行评议文献被排除在外。
结果
共检索到 306 篇文章,对其进行分类和定性分析,以揭示 GCC 电子卫生研究的现状。使用 NVivo 10.0 定性软件确定并总结了国家特定和 GCC 范围内的主要主题。最常见的研究类型是概述(35.0%),常见的研究设计包括案例研究(26.8%)和描述性文章(46.4%)。重要主题包括:电子卫生的预期国家利益、电子病历的实施和满意度、医学教育中的在线技术、创新系统(案例研究)以及信息安全和个人健康信息。
讨论
这是对 GCC 电子卫生的首次全面分析性文献综述。确定了重要的研究差距:检索到的成本效益分析、对照干预研究或针对性别和宗教问题的研究很少。