Mokhtarzadeh Fatemeh, Petersen Luba
Department of Economics, University of Victoria, 3800 Finnerty Road, Victoria, BC V8P 5C2 Canada.
Department of Economics, Simon Fraser University, 8888 University Drive, Burnaby, BC V5A 1S6 Canada.
Exp Econ. 2021;24(3):883-918. doi: 10.1007/s10683-020-09684-6. Epub 2020 Nov 24.
Central banks are increasingly communicating their economic outlook in an effort to manage the public and financial market participants' expectations. We provide original causal evidence that the information communicated and the assumptions underlying a central bank's projection can matter for expectation formation and aggregate stability. Using a between-subject design, we systematically vary the central bank's projected forecasts in an experimental macroeconomy where subjects are incentivized to forecast the output gap and inflation. Without projections, subjects exhibit a wide range of heuristics, with the modal heuristic involving a significant backward-looking component. Ex-Ante Rational dual projections of the output gap and inflation significantly reduce the number of subjects' using backward-looking heuristics and nudge expectations in the direction of the rational expectations equilibrium. Ex-Ante Rational interest rate projections are cognitively challenging to employ and have limited effects on the distribution of heuristics. Adaptive dual projections generate unintended inflation volatility by inducing boundedly-rational forecasters to employ the projection and model-consistent forecasters to utilize the projection as a proxy for aggregate expectations. All projections reduce output gap disagreement but increase inflation disagreement. Central bank credibility is significantly diminished when the central bank makes larger forecast errors when communicating a relatively more complex projection. Our findings suggest that inflation-targeting central banks should strategically ignore agents' irrationalities when constructing their projections and communicate easy-to-process information.
各国央行越来越多地传达其经济前景,以管理公众和金融市场参与者的预期。我们提供了原始的因果证据,表明央行传达的信息及其预测所依据的假设对预期形成和总体稳定可能至关重要。我们采用主体间设计,在一个实验性宏观经济环境中系统地改变央行的预测,在该环境中,受试者被激励去预测产出缺口和通货膨胀。在没有预测的情况下,受试者表现出各种各样的启发式方法,其中典型的启发式方法涉及显著的后视成分。产出缺口和通货膨胀的事前理性双重预测显著减少了使用后视启发式方法的受试者数量,并将预期朝着理性预期均衡的方向推动。事前理性利率预测在认知上难以采用,对启发式方法的分布影响有限。适应性双重预测通过诱导有限理性的预测者采用该预测,并使模型一致的预测者将该预测用作总体预期的代理,从而产生意外的通货膨胀波动。所有预测都减少了产出缺口的分歧,但增加了通货膨胀的分歧。当央行在传达相对更复杂的预测时出现较大的预测误差时,央行的可信度会显著降低。我们的研究结果表明,以通货膨胀为目标的央行在构建预测时应从战略上忽略主体的非理性因素,并传达易于处理的信息。