Centre for Rural & Remote Health, James Cook University, Mount Isa, Australia.
College of Medicine and Dentistry, James Cook University, Townsville, Australia.
Prim Health Care Res Dev. 2021 Nov 3;22:e63. doi: 10.1017/S1463423621000487.
In Australia, around 3.6 million people suffer from hearing loss, more than 1.3 million with preventable hearing conditions. Ear diseases are prevalent in Indigenous populations, particularly children and are associated with poor educational outcomes and subsequent high rates of unemployment and incarceration. In Australia, rural and remote communities have rates of middle ear perforations five times the rate that the World Health Organisation regards to be a significant public health problem.Barriers to accessing ear health services have been identified including gaps in testing during the 'early years' and difficulty in accessing these services. Reducing the risk of hearing loss through improved ear health care can directly impact the ability to learn and develop. Collaboration between community, health providers and government is crucial to ensure necessary support for change. An opportunity presents for rural community pharmacists, who are both qualified and accessible to provide an ear health programme and thus improve health outcomes for both Indigenous and non-Indigenous Australians in their communities.
The aim of this study was to identify published evidence of pharmacists' involvement in ear health care interventions to inform the development of ear health services able to be delivered in rural community pharmacy in Australia.
The search strategy was applied to the following electronic databases: MEDLINE, Scopus, CINAHL, Emcare, Cochrane, Google Scholar and Google.Study selection articles were included if they described an ear health intervention in a community pharmacy setting. The interventions reported in the articles were evaluated for their inclusion of effectiveness, whether the service was sustainable, and the inclusion of enablers and barriers to the provision of ear care. The articles were also thematically analysed using the Deadly Ears Deadly Kids Deadly Communities Framework. A total 8427 articles were identified and evaluated against inclusion and exclusion criteria, with eleven eligible articles suitable for inclusion in the review. The articles included were conducted in Australia (n = 4), England (n = 4), United States of America (n = 2) and Brazil (n = 1). The ear health interventions identified included hearing screening (n = 3), otoscopy pilot studies (n = 2), audiometry services (n = 1), specific education for undergraduate pharmacy students (n = 2) and a pharmacy-based clinic (n = 3). Effectiveness and sustainability were not formally reported in any of the included articles. Positive outcomes, funding availability, consumer access to community pharmacy, cost savings for consumers and improved connection to health providers were identified as enablers. Difficulty in attracting funding was the most commonly reported barrier.
Improving ear health of both Indigenous and non-Indigenous peoples through services provided in community pharmacy presents as an important opportunity for rural pharmacists. Pharmacists are accessible and thus well placed to improve ear healthcare and resultant quality of life for these vulnerable populations. This review has identified factors required to effectively develop ear health models of care in community pharmacy including a pharmacist training program, continuous funding to ensure sustainability and support from pharmacy stakeholders and the community.
在澳大利亚,约有 360 万人患有听力损失,其中超过 130 万人患有可预防的听力状况。耳部疾病在原住民中很普遍,尤其是儿童,与教育成果不佳以及随后的高失业率和监禁率有关。在澳大利亚,农村和偏远社区的中耳穿孔率是世界卫生组织认为存在重大公共卫生问题的穿孔率的五倍。获得耳部健康服务的障碍包括“早期”检测中的差距以及难以获得这些服务。通过改善耳部保健来降低听力损失的风险,可以直接影响学习和发展的能力。社区、卫生提供者和政府之间的合作对于确保为变革提供必要的支持至关重要。农村社区药剂师提供耳部健康计划的机会出现了,他们既合格又可及,可以改善他们社区中土著和非土著澳大利亚人的健康结果。
本研究旨在确定已发表的关于药剂师参与耳部保健干预措施的证据,以为澳大利亚农村社区药剂师能够提供的耳部保健服务的发展提供信息。
该搜索策略应用于以下电子数据库:MEDLINE、Scopus、CINAHL、Emcare、Cochrane、Google Scholar 和 Google。如果文章描述了社区药房环境中的耳部健康干预措施,则将文章纳入研究。评估文章中报告的干预措施的有效性,评估服务的可持续性,以及纳入提供耳部护理的促进因素和障碍。文章还使用致命的耳朵致命的孩子致命的社区框架进行了主题分析。总共确定了 8427 篇文章,并根据纳入和排除标准进行了评估,其中 11 篇符合纳入标准的文章适合纳入审查。文章包括在澳大利亚(n=4)、英格兰(n=4)、美国(n=2)和巴西(n=1)进行的研究。确定的耳部健康干预措施包括听力筛查(n=3)、耳镜检查试点研究(n=2)、听力计服务(n=1)、本科药学学生的特定教育(n=2)和药房诊所(n=3)。纳入的任何文章均未正式报告有效性和可持续性。可及性、消费者获得社区药房、消费者节省成本以及与卫生提供者的联系改善被确定为促进因素。资金筹集困难是报告最多的障碍。
通过社区药房提供的服务改善土著和非土著人民的耳部健康,为农村药剂师提供了一个重要机会。药剂师可及,因此非常适合改善这些弱势群体的耳部保健和由此产生的生活质量。本综述确定了在社区药房有效开发耳部保健护理模式所需的因素,包括药剂师培训计划、持续资金以确保可持续性,以及来自药房利益相关者和社区的支持。