Faculty of Management, University of Tehran, Tehran, Iran.
Mehr Alborz University, Tehran, Iran.
J Healthc Eng. 2021 Oct 27;2021:1964054. doi: 10.1155/2021/1964054. eCollection 2021.
In today's competitive environment, one of the new tools in the field of information technology is business or organizational dashboards that are a backup in the process of strategic management of organizations. The purpose of the current research is to provide a framework to design the healthcare dashboard through technical architecture with fulfilling the decision-makers' requirements. In this study, a common qualitative research method, metasynthesis, is applied, including a seven-step set of research questions, conducting systematic literature search and selection of suitable papers, data extraction, analysis and findings of the qualitative composition, quality control, and presentation of findings. During this process, 102 articles were found by saturation of information resources and then 12 articles were selected for extracting data using acceptance and rejection criteria. A critical evaluation method was used to evaluate the quality of selected articles. After investigating the selected articles and scoring them, in terms of quality, one article was very good, 10 articles were good, and one article was moderate. Then, with regard to the principles and guidelines of technical architecture, the required information was extracted from the selected articles and was analyzed with the method of open, axial, and selective coding. Following the steps of metasynthesis methods, the principles extracted with major and minor titles principles and guidelines in the form of multilayered system architecture including presentation layer, application layer, data layer, and technical infrastructure layer were classified. In the obtained framework, 15 indicators as the main principles and 66 subcriteria as the subsidiary principles for the design and technical architecture of enterprise dashboards were identified.
在当今竞争激烈的环境中,信息技术领域的新工具之一是业务或组织仪表板,它是组织战略管理过程中的备份。本研究的目的是通过满足决策者需求的技术架构提供设计医疗保健仪表板的框架。在这项研究中,应用了一种常见的定性研究方法——元综合,包括一套七步的研究问题,系统地进行文献搜索和选择合适的论文,数据提取,定性组成的分析和发现,质量控制以及研究结果的呈现。在这个过程中,通过信息资源的饱和发现了 102 篇文章,然后根据接受和拒绝标准选择了 12 篇文章进行数据提取。使用了一种批判性评估方法来评估所选文章的质量。在调查了选定的文章并对其进行评分后,就质量而言,有一篇文章非常好,10 篇文章良好,一篇文章中等。然后,根据技术架构的原则和指南,从选定的文章中提取所需的信息,并采用开放式、轴向式和选择性编码的方法进行分析。在元综合方法的步骤之后,以多层系统架构的形式(包括表示层、应用层、数据层和技术基础设施层)提取了带有主要和次要标题的原则和指南,并对其进行了分类。在所获得的框架中,确定了 15 个作为主要原则的指标和 66 个作为企业仪表板设计和技术架构的辅助原则的子标准。