Boussion Nicolas, Schick Ulrike, Dissaux Gurvan, Ollivier Luc, Goasduff Gaëlle, Pradier Olivier, Valeri Antoine, Visvikis Dimitris
LaTIM, INSERM, UMR 1101, Univ Brest, Brest, France.
Radiation Oncology Department, CHU, Brest, France.
J Contemp Brachytherapy. 2021 Oct;13(5):541-548. doi: 10.5114/jcb.2021.109789. Epub 2021 Oct 7.
Low-dose-rate brachytherapy is a key treatment for low-risk or favorable intermediate-risk prostate cancer. The number of radioactive seeds inserted during the procedure depends on prostate volume, and is not easy to predict without pre-planning. Consequently, a large number of unused seeds may be left after treatment. The objective of the present study was to predict the exact number of seeds for future patients using machine learning and a database of 409 treatments.
Database consisted of 18 dosimetric and efficiency parameters for each of 409 cases. Nine predictive algorithms based on machine-learning were compared in this database, which was divided into training group (80%) and test group (20%). Ten-fold cross-validation was applied to obtain robust statistics. The best algorithm was then used to build an abacus able to predict number of implanted seeds from expected prostate volume only. As an evaluation, the abacus was also applied on an independent series of 38 consecutive patients.
The best coefficients of determination were given by support vector regression, with values attaining 0.928, 0.948, and 0.968 for training set, test set, and whole set, respectively. In terms of predicted seeds in test group, mean square error, median absolute error, mean absolute error, and maximum error were 2.55, 0.92, 1.21, and 7.29, respectively. The use of obtained abacus in 38 additional patients resulted in saving of 493 seeds (393 vs. 886 remaining seeds).
Machine-learning-based abacus proposed in this study aims at estimating the necessary number of seeds for future patients according to past experience. This new abacus, based on 409 treatments and successfully tested in 38 new patients, is a good alternative to non-specific recommendations.
低剂量率近距离放射治疗是低风险或预后良好的中风险前列腺癌的关键治疗方法。手术过程中植入的放射性粒子数量取决于前列腺体积,在没有预先规划的情况下很难预测。因此,治疗后可能会留下大量未使用的粒子。本研究的目的是使用机器学习和一个包含409例治疗数据的数据库来预测未来患者所需的精确粒子数量。
数据库包含409例病例中每例的18个剂量学和效率参数。在该数据库中比较了9种基于机器学习的预测算法,数据库被分为训练组(80%)和测试组(20%)。采用十折交叉验证以获得可靠的统计数据。然后使用最佳算法构建一个算盘,该算盘能够仅根据预期的前列腺体积预测植入粒子的数量。作为评估,该算盘也应用于38例连续患者的独立系列。
支持向量回归给出了最佳决定系数,训练集、测试集和整个数据集的值分别达到0.928、0.948和0.968。在测试组中预测粒子数量方面,均方误差、中位数绝对误差、平均绝对误差和最大误差分别为2.55、0.92、1.21和7.29。在另外38例患者中使用所得算盘节省了493个粒子(剩余粒子分别为393个和886个)。
本研究中提出的基于机器学习的算盘旨在根据以往经验估计未来患者所需的粒子数量。这个基于409例治疗数据并在38例新患者中成功测试的新算盘,是替代非特异性建议的良好选择。