Department of Clinical Neurosciences & Hotchkiss Brain Institute, University of Calgary, Calgary, Alberta, Canada.
Department of Community Health Sciences & O'Brien Institute of Public Health, University of Calgary, Calgary, Alberta, Canada.
BMJ Open. 2021 Nov 11;11(11):e051185. doi: 10.1136/bmjopen-2021-051185.
To date, there is no broadly accepted dementia risk score for use in individuals with mild cognitive impairment (MCI), partly because there are few large datasets available for model development. When evidence is limited, the knowledge and experience of experts becomes more crucial for risk stratification and providing MCI patients with prognosis. Structured expert elicitation (SEE) includes formal methods to quantify experts' beliefs and help experts to express their beliefs in a quantitative form, reducing biases in the process. This study proposes to (1) assess experts' beliefs about important predictors for 3-year dementia risk in persons with MCI through SEE methodology and (2) to integrate expert knowledge and patient data to derive dementia risk scores in persons with MCI using a Bayesian approach.
This study will use a combination of SEE methodology, prospectively collected clinical data, and statistical modelling to derive a dementia risk score in persons with MCI . Clinical expert knowledge will be quantified using SEE methodology that involves the selection and training of the experts, administration of questionnaire for eliciting expert knowledge, discussion meetings and results aggregation. Patient data from the Prospective Registry for Persons with Memory Symptoms of the Cognitive Neurosciences Clinic at the University of Calgary; the Alzheimer's Disease Neuroimaging Initiative; and the National Alzheimer's Coordinating Center's Uniform Data Set will be used for model training and validation. Bayesian Cox models will be used to incorporate patient data and elicited data to predict 3-year dementia risk.
This study will develop a robust dementia risk score that incorporates clinician expert knowledge with patient data for accurate risk stratification, prognosis and management of dementia.
迄今为止,由于缺乏可用于模型开发的大型数据集,针对轻度认知障碍(MCI)患者,尚无被广泛接受的痴呆风险评分。当证据有限时,专家的知识和经验对于风险分层和为 MCI 患者提供预后就变得更为重要。结构化专家 elicitation(SEE)包括量化专家信念的正式方法,并帮助专家以定量形式表达其信念,从而减少过程中的偏差。本研究旨在(1)通过 SEE 方法评估专家对 MCI 患者 3 年内发生痴呆风险的重要预测因素的看法,以及(2)通过贝叶斯方法将专家知识和患者数据整合起来,为 MCI 患者推导痴呆风险评分。
本研究将结合 SEE 方法、前瞻性收集的临床数据和统计建模,来为 MCI 患者推导痴呆风险评分。临床专家知识将通过 SEE 方法进行量化,该方法包括专家的选择和培训、专家知识 elicitation 问卷的管理、讨论会议和结果汇总。来自卡尔加里认知神经科学诊所的记忆症状患者前瞻性登记处、阿尔茨海默病神经影像学倡议和国家阿尔茨海默病协调中心的统一数据集的患者数据将用于模型训练和验证。贝叶斯 Cox 模型将用于整合患者数据和 elicitation 数据来预测 3 年内的痴呆风险。
本研究将开发一种稳健的痴呆风险评分,该评分将临床医生的专家知识与患者数据相结合,以实现准确的风险分层、预后和痴呆管理。