Swedish/Edmonds Hospital, Edmonds, Washington, USA.
J Healthc Risk Manag. 2022 Jan;41(3):14-23. doi: 10.1002/jhrm.21487. Epub 2021 Nov 17.
Risk managers and ethicists monitor adherence to codes of conduct in the delivery of medical services and proactively participate with providers to create protocols that minimize the moral, ethical, and legal risks inherent in many commonly used medical protocols. "Code/no code" medical orders work well for patients at the extremes who always or never want to undergo a procedure, but they create troubling uncertainties for others by preventing them from expressly requesting procedures under some circumstances but not others. Obeying binary orders such as DNAR (Do Not Attempt Resuscitation) can allow deaths that a patient might want to delay or can expose patients to prolonged suffering they wish to avoid. These risks can be reduced by: (1) fully explaining the nature of proposed interventions and their possible beneficial and adverse effects in varying circumstances; and (2) replacing the traditional dichotomy with a continuum of options from always, through conditionally sometime, to never orders adapted to a range of situations and preferences. The Conditional Medical Orders (CMO) form summarizes patients' preferences regarding resuscitation, ventilation, and artificial hydration and nutrition (ANH) is an efficient way to increases the chance that patients will undergo only the treatments they want.
风险经理和伦理学家监测医疗服务提供过程中行为准则的遵守情况,并与提供者积极合作,制定协议,将许多常用医疗协议中固有的道德、伦理和法律风险降到最低。“有/无代码”医疗指令对于总是或从不希望接受某项程序的极端患者效果很好,但它们通过在某些情况下阻止患者明确要求某项程序,而在其他情况下又允许他们进行,从而给其他人带来了令人困扰的不确定性。遵守 DNAR(不进行复苏尝试)等二进制指令可能会导致患者本希望延迟的死亡,或者使患者遭受他们希望避免的长时间痛苦。这些风险可以通过以下方式降低:(1)充分解释拟议干预措施的性质及其在不同情况下可能产生的有益和不利影响;(2)用一系列从总是、有条件地有时到从不的选项替代传统的二分法,这些选项适用于一系列情况和偏好。条件医疗指令 (CMO) 表格总结了患者对复苏、通气和人工水合与营养 (ANH) 的偏好,这是增加患者仅接受他们想要的治疗的机会的有效方法。