Erdal Feyzi S, Özman Oktay
Haseki Training and Research Hospital İstanbul, Turkey.
Urology Clinic, Gazismanpasa Training and Research Hospital İstanbul, Turkey.
Am J Clin Exp Urol. 2021 Oct 15;9(5):378-383. eCollection 2021.
The aim of this study was to evaluate the learning curve of inexperienced surgeon who can perform the operation on their own for access sheatless and radiation-free retrograde intrarenal surgery (RIRS) technique. Results of 70 consecutive patients who have renal stones and underwent RIRS which performed by a single surgeon were evaluated retrospectively. Cumulative stone free rates and fragmentation efficacy were taken as the primary outcomes for the learning curve analyses. Stone free rate was 74% (52/70). The learning curve constructed with moving average of cumulative stone free rates showed that learning curve of sheathless RIRS consisted of three phases; rapid ascent (0-15: phase 1), slight decline (16-35: phase 2) and plateau (36-70: phase 3). The number of case needed to obtain a final plateau in stone free rates was about 35. Fragmentation efficacy reached a plateau after 50 cases. The learning curve of access sheatless and radiation-free RIRS reached plateau phase after 35-50 cases. This steep learning curve points out that surgeons do not need to experience the classical RIRS technique before starting to perform access sheatless and radiation-free technique.
本研究的目的是评估能够独立开展无鞘无辐射逆行性肾内手术(RIRS)技术的经验不足的外科医生的学习曲线。对70例连续患有肾结石且由单一外科医生实施RIRS手术的患者结果进行回顾性评估。累积无结石率和碎石效果作为学习曲线分析的主要结果。无结石率为74%(52/70)。用累积无结石率的移动平均值构建的学习曲线表明,无鞘RIRS的学习曲线包括三个阶段:快速上升期(0 - 15例:第1阶段)、轻微下降期(16 - 35例:第2阶段)和平稳期(36 - 70例:第3阶段)。达到最终无结石率平稳期所需的病例数约为35例。碎石效果在50例后达到平稳期。无鞘无辐射RIRS的学习曲线在35 - 50例后达到平稳期。这条陡峭的学习曲线表明,外科医生在开始实施无鞘无辐射技术之前无需经历传统的RIRS技术。