Yang Albert F, Nguyen Morgan, Li Alvin W, Lee Brad, Chun Keum San, Wu Ellen, Fishbein Anna B, Paller Amy S, Xu Shuai
University of Illinois at Chicago College of Medicine, Chicago, Illinois.
Department of Dermatology, Northwestern University Feinberg School of Medicine, Chicago, Illinois.
JAAD Int. 2021 Aug 17;5:19-32. doi: 10.1016/j.jdin.2021.06.005. eCollection 2021 Dec.
Pruritus is a common symptom across various dermatologic conditions, with a negative impact on quality of life. Devices to quantify itch objectively primarily use scratch as a proxy. This review compares and evaluates the performance of technologies aimed at objectively measuring scratch behavior.
Articles identified from literature searches performed in October 2020 were reviewed and those that did not report a primary statistical performance measure (eg, sensitivity, specificity) were excluded. The articles were independently reviewed by 2 authors.
The literature search resulted in 6231 articles, of which 24 met eligibility criteria. Studies were categorized by technology, with actigraphy being the most studied (n = 21). Wrist actigraphy's performance is poorer in pruritic patients and inherently limited in finger-dominant scratch detection. It has moderate correlations with objective measures (Eczema and Area Severity Index/Investigator's Global Assessment: r(ρ) = 0.70-0.76), but correlations with subjective measures are poor (r = 0.06, r(ρ) = 0.18-0.40 for itch measured using a visual analog scale). This may be due to varied subjective perception of itch or actigraphy's underestimation of scratch.
Actigraphy's large variability in performance and limited understanding of its specificity for scratch merits larger studies looking at validation of data analysis algorithms and device performance, particularly within target patient populations.
瘙痒是各种皮肤病的常见症状,对生活质量有负面影响。客观量化瘙痒的设备主要将抓挠作为替代指标。本综述比较并评估了旨在客观测量抓挠行为的技术的性能。
对2020年10月进行的文献检索中识别出的文章进行了综述,排除了未报告主要统计性能指标(如敏感性、特异性)的文章。这些文章由两位作者独立评审。
文献检索共得到6231篇文章,其中24篇符合纳入标准。研究按技术分类,活动记录仪的研究最多(n = 21)。手腕活动记录仪在瘙痒患者中的表现较差,在以手指为主的抓挠检测方面存在固有局限性。它与客观指标有中度相关性(湿疹和面积严重程度指数/研究者整体评估:r(ρ)=0.70 - 0.76),但与主观指标的相关性较差(使用视觉模拟量表测量瘙痒时,r = 0.06,r(ρ)= = 0.18 - 0.40)。这可能是由于对瘙痒的主观感知不同,或者活动记录仪对抓挠的低估。
活动记录仪性能的巨大变异性以及对其抓挠特异性的有限了解,值得开展更大规模的研究,以验证数据分析算法和设备性能,尤其是在目标患者群体中。