Relyea Bridget, Wringe Alison, Afaneh Osama, Malamas Ioannis, Teodoro Nicholas, Ghafour Mohammed, Scott Jennifer
Women and Health Alliance International, Erbil, Iraq.
Women and Health Alliance International, Paris, France.
Front Glob Womens Health. 2021 May 26;2:662256. doi: 10.3389/fgwh.2021.662256. eCollection 2021.
The health system in northern Iraq has been weakened by conflict and the internal displacement of over three million people. Mobile phone-based interventions (mHealth) may improve maternal and neonatal health outcomes by enabling emergency referrals, facilitating communication between patients and providers, and improving patient data management; however, they have not been sufficiently studied in conflict-affected settings. We explored stakeholders' perspectives on challenges to obstetric referrals and the feasibility and acceptability of a mobile phone-based application to reduce delays in reaching emergency obstetric care in order to inform its development. We conducted a qualitative study in the Kurdistan region of northern Iraq from May to July, 2018. Using purposive sampling, we carried out 15 semi-structured interviews with coordination actors including healthcare management staff, government health officials, non-government health program managers and ambulance staff. The interviews explored obstetric care delivery, referral processes, mobile phone usage and mHealth implementation strategies. Eleven focus group discussions, which incorporated participatory activities on similar topics, were conducted with ambulance drivers, hospital and primary health center staff. Audio-recorded, transcribed and translated data were coded iteratively to identify emerging concepts, and analyzed thematically. Sixty-eight stakeholders (36 women and 32 men) participated. Challenges regarding the referral system included resource limitations, security concerns, costs and women's reluctance to be transported in male-staffed ambulances. In terms of obstetric care and decision-making, participants noted gaps in communication and coordination of services with the current paper-based system between health care providers, ambulance drivers, and hospital staff. Ambulance drivers reported incurring delays through lack of patient information, poor road conditions, and security issues. A prototype mobile phone application was found to be acceptable based on perceived usefulness to address some of the challenges to safe obstetric care and focused on phone usage, access to information, Global Positioning System (GPS), connectivity, cost, and user-friendliness. However, the feasibility of the innovation was considered in relation to implementation challenges that were identified, including poor connectivity, and digital literacy. Implementation of the app would need to account for the humanitarian context, cultural and gender norms regarding obstetric care, and would require substantial commitment and engagement from policymakers and practitioners.
伊拉克北部的卫生系统因冲突和超过300万人的境内流离失所而遭到削弱。基于手机的干预措施(移动健康)可通过实现紧急转诊、促进患者与医疗服务提供者之间的沟通以及改善患者数据管理来改善孕产妇和新生儿的健康结局;然而,在受冲突影响的环境中,对这些措施尚未进行充分研究。我们探讨了利益相关者对产科转诊挑战的看法,以及一款基于手机的应用程序在减少获得紧急产科护理延误方面的可行性和可接受性,以便为其开发提供参考。2018年5月至7月,我们在伊拉克北部的库尔德地区进行了一项定性研究。采用目的抽样法,我们对包括医疗保健管理人员、政府卫生官员、非政府卫生项目管理人员和救护车工作人员在内的协调人员进行了15次半结构化访谈。访谈探讨了产科护理提供、转诊流程、手机使用情况和移动健康实施策略。我们与救护车司机、医院和初级卫生中心工作人员进行了11次焦点小组讨论,其中纳入了关于类似主题的参与性活动。对录音、转录和翻译的数据进行反复编码,以识别新出现的概念,并进行主题分析。68名利益相关者(36名女性和32名男性)参与了研究。转诊系统面临的挑战包括资源限制、安全担忧、成本以及女性不愿乘坐由男性工作人员驾驶的救护车。在产科护理和决策方面,参与者指出,在当前基于纸质系统的情况下,医疗服务提供者、救护车司机和医院工作人员之间在服务沟通与协调方面存在差距。救护车司机报告称,由于缺乏患者信息、路况不佳和安全问题而导致延误。基于其在应对安全产科护理挑战方面的感知有用性,一款手机应用程序原型被认为是可接受的,该应用程序侧重于手机使用、信息获取、全球定位系统(GPS)、连接性、成本和用户友好性。然而,该创新措施的可行性是根据所确定的实施挑战来考虑的,包括连接性差和数字素养问题。该应用程序的实施需要考虑人道主义背景、产科护理方面的文化和性别规范,并且需要政策制定者和从业者做出大量承诺并积极参与。