Li Dingsheng, Li Li
School of Public Health, University of Nevada, Reno, NV 89557, USA.
Toxics. 2021 Nov 15;9(11):308. doi: 10.3390/toxics9110308.
The linear dose-response relationship has long been assumed in assessments of health risk from an incremental chemical emission relative to background emissions. In this study, we systematically examine the relevancy of such an assumption with real-world data. We used the reported emission data, as background emissions, from the 2017 U.S. National Emission Inventory for 95 organic chemicals to estimate the central tendencies of exposures of the general U.S. population. Previously published nonlinear dose-response relationships for chemicals were used to estimate health risk from exposure. We also explored and identified four intervals of exposure in which the nonlinear dose-response relationship may be linearly approximated with fixed slopes. Predicted rates of exposure to these 95 chemicals are all within the lowest of the four intervals and associated with low health risk. The health risk may be overestimated if a slope on the dose-response relationship extrapolated from toxicological assays based on high response rates is used for a marginal increase in emission not substantially higher than background emissions. To improve the confidence of human health risk estimates for chemicals, future efforts should focus on deriving a more accurate dose-response relationship at lower response rates and interface it with exposure assessments.
长期以来,在评估相对于背景排放的化学物质增量排放对健康的风险时,一直假定存在线性剂量反应关系。在本研究中,我们使用实际数据系统地检验了这一假设的相关性。我们将2017年美国国家排放清单报告的95种有机化学品的排放数据用作背景排放,以估计美国普通人群的暴露集中趋势。利用先前发表的化学品非线性剂量反应关系来估计暴露导致的健康风险。我们还探索并确定了四个暴露区间,在这些区间内,非线性剂量反应关系可以用固定斜率进行线性近似。预测的这95种化学品的暴露率均处于四个区间中的最低区间,且健康风险较低。如果将基于高反应率的毒理学试验推断出的剂量反应关系斜率用于排放量仅略高于背景排放的边际增加量,那么健康风险可能会被高估。为提高对化学品人类健康风险估计的可信度,未来的工作应侧重于在较低反应率下得出更准确的剂量反应关系,并将其与暴露评估相结合。