Cockerell Oliver C, Iino Hayes Natalie, Sylvester Richard
The London Clinic, London W1G 6HL, UK.
Queen Mary University of London, Mile End E1 4NS, UK.
JRSM Open. 2021 Nov 18;12(11):20542704211055558. doi: 10.1177/20542704211055558. eCollection 2021 Nov.
The present study aims to provide a narrative review of the literature surrounding concussion and head injury in football and its clarity in evaluating the risk of long-term neurological disease.
Epidemiological studies have shown correlations between participation in professional football and increased incidence of neurodegenerative disease and there have been reports of chronic traumatic encephalopathy (CTE) in the brains of former players in autopsy. These findings have been assumed by some to be the result of repetitive brain injury from head injuries and/or from heading the ball over a player's career. Data linking increased heading exposure with dementia is conflicting, and studies are limited by the reliance on retrospection and undocumented reports of concussion. It remains unclear whether CTE is unique to sportsmen or a variant of dementia pathology endemic in the population.
Although logically appealing, there is no current evidence that heading is the cause of neurodegeneration amongst footballers and risks should be balanced by the protective mental and physical benefits of the sport. Physicians have an important role in providing balanced views in this emotive and controversial area.
本研究旨在对围绕足球运动中脑震荡和头部损伤及其在评估长期神经疾病风险方面的清晰度的文献进行叙述性综述。
流行病学研究表明,参与职业足球运动与神经退行性疾病发病率增加之间存在关联,并且尸检报告显示前足球运动员大脑中存在慢性创伤性脑病(CTE)。一些人认为这些发现是球员职业生涯中头部受伤和/或头球导致的重复性脑损伤的结果。将增加的头球暴露与痴呆症联系起来的数据相互矛盾,并且研究受到对脑震荡回顾性和未记录报告的依赖的限制。目前尚不清楚CTE是运动员特有的,还是人群中普遍存在的痴呆症病理学变体。
尽管从逻辑上看很有吸引力,但目前没有证据表明头球是足球运动员神经退行性变的原因,并且风险应该与这项运动带来的心理和身体保护益处相平衡。在这个情绪化且有争议的领域,医生在提供平衡观点方面发挥着重要作用。