LUCAS Center for Care Research and Consultancy, KU Leuven, 3000 Leuven, Belgium.
Center for Sociological Research, KU Leuven, 3000 Leuven, Belgium.
Int J Environ Res Public Health. 2021 Nov 11;18(22):11845. doi: 10.3390/ijerph182211845.
One of the primary objectives of health systems is to provide a fair system by providing a comprehensive and holistic approach to caregiving rather than focusing on a single aspect of a person's care needs. This approach is often embodied by using standardized care assessments across health and social care settings. These assessments are completed by professional assessors and yield vital information regarding a person's health or contextual characteristics (e.g., civic engagement, psychosocial wellbeing, environmental characteristics, informal care). However, these scores may be subject to bias that endangers the fairness of the health system. In this study, we investigate to what extent socio-economic and psychological indicators and assessor-related indicators are associated with BelRAI Screener care assessment scores amongst 743 community-dwelling adults nested within 92 assessors in Flanders, Belgium. Findings indicate that there is significant variance in scores at the assessor-level. Socio-psychological characteristics of clients are associated with scores: being fluent in Dutch and providing informal care are associated with low care dependency, while living with children, feelings of depression, and the presence of an informal caregiver during assessment are associated with high care dependency. We discuss the importance of rigorous assessor training and the potential for socio-psychological factors to contribute to the allocation of welfare benefits in light of the Flemish home care system's potential (lack of) fairness.
卫生系统的主要目标之一是提供一个公平的系统,通过提供全面和整体的护理方法,而不是关注一个人护理需求的单一方面。这种方法通常通过在卫生和社会保健环境中使用标准化的护理评估来体现。这些评估由专业评估员完成,并提供有关个人健康或环境特征(例如公民参与、社会心理福利、环境特征、非正式护理)的重要信息。然而,这些分数可能存在偏见,危及卫生系统的公平性。在这项研究中,我们调查了社会经济和心理指标以及评估员相关指标在多大程度上与比利时佛兰德斯的 92 名评估员中的 743 名居住在社区的成年人的 BelRAI 筛查护理评估分数相关。研究结果表明,评估员层面的分数存在显著差异。客户的社会心理特征与分数有关:能说流利的荷兰语和提供非正式护理与低护理依赖性有关,而与孩子一起生活、感到抑郁以及在评估期间有非正式护理者与高护理依赖性有关。我们讨论了严格评估员培训的重要性,以及社会心理因素在佛兰德斯家庭护理系统潜在(缺乏)公平性的情况下对福利分配的潜在贡献。