Liu Wen-Cheng, Lin Chin, Lin Chin-Sheng, Tsai Min-Chien, Chen Sy-Jou, Tsai Shih-Hung, Lin Wei-Shiang, Lee Chia-Cheng, Tsao Tien-Ping, Cheng Cheng-Chung
Division of Cardiology, Department of Internal Medicine, Tri-Service General Hospital, National Defense Medical Center, Taipei 114, Taiwan.
Medical Technology Education Center, School of Medicine, National Defense Medical Center, Taipei 114, Taiwan.
J Pers Med. 2021 Nov 4;11(11):1149. doi: 10.3390/jpm11111149.
(1) Background: While an artificial intelligence (AI)-based, cardiologist-level, deep-learning model for detecting acute myocardial infarction (AMI), based on a 12-lead electrocardiogram (ECG), has been established to have extraordinary capabilities, its real-world performance and clinical applications are currently unknown. (2) Methods and Results: To set up an artificial intelligence-based alarm strategy (AI-S) for detecting AMI, we assembled a strategy development cohort including 25,002 visits from August 2019 to April 2020 and a prospective validation cohort including 14,296 visits from May to August 2020 at an emergency department. The components of AI-S consisted of chest pain symptoms, a 12-lead ECG, and high-sensitivity troponin I. The primary endpoint was to assess the performance of AI-S in the prospective validation cohort by evaluating F-measure, precision, and recall. The secondary endpoint was to evaluate the impact on door-to-balloon (DtoB) time before and after AI-S implementation in STEMI patients treated with primary percutaneous coronary intervention (PPCI). Patients with STEMI were alerted precisely by AI-S (F-measure = 0.932, precision of 93.2%, recall of 93.2%). Strikingly, in comparison with pre-AI-S (N = 57) and post-AI-S (N = 32) implantation in STEMI protocol, the median ECG-to-cardiac catheterization laboratory activation (EtoCCLA) time was significantly reduced from 6.0 (IQR, 5.0-8.0 min) to 4.0 min (IQR, 3.0-5.0 min) ( < 0.01). The median DtoB time was shortened from 69 (IQR, 61.0-82.0 min) to 61 min (IQR, 56.8-73.2 min) ( = 0.037). (3) Conclusions: AI-S offers front-line physicians a timely and reliable diagnostic decision-support system, thereby significantly reducing EtoCCLA and DtoB time, and facilitating the PPCI process. Nevertheless, large-scale, multi-institute, prospective, or randomized control studies are necessary to further confirm its real-world performance.
(1)背景:基于12导联心电图(ECG)检测急性心肌梗死(AMI)的人工智能(AI)驱动的心脏病专家水平深度学习模型已被证实具有非凡能力,但其在现实世界中的性能和临床应用目前尚不清楚。(2)方法与结果:为建立基于人工智能的AMI检测报警策略(AI-S),我们组建了一个策略开发队列,包括2019年8月至2020年4月的25002次就诊,以及一个前瞻性验证队列,包括2020年5月至8月在急诊科的14296次就诊。AI-S的组成部分包括胸痛症状、12导联心电图和高敏肌钙蛋白I。主要终点是通过评估F值、精确度和召回率来评估AI-S在前瞻性验证队列中的性能。次要终点是评估在接受直接经皮冠状动脉介入治疗(PPCI)的ST段抬高型心肌梗死(STEMI)患者中,AI-S实施前后对门球时间(DtoB)的影响。STEMI患者通过AI-S得到了准确警报(F值=0.932,精确度93.2%,召回率93.2%)。令人惊讶的是,与STEMI方案中AI-S实施前(N = 57)和实施后(N = 32)的植入情况相比,心电图至心脏导管实验室激活(EtoCCLA)的中位时间从6.0(四分位间距,5.0 - 8.0分钟)显著缩短至4.0分钟(四分位间距,3.0 - 5.0分钟)(<0.01)。DtoB的中位时间从69(四分位间距,61.0 - 82.0分钟)缩短至61分钟(四分位间距,56.8 - 73.2分钟)(P = 0.037)。(3)结论:AI-S为一线医生提供了一个及时且可靠的诊断决策支持系统,从而显著缩短了EtoCCLA和DtoB时间,并促进了PPCI过程。然而,需要大规模、多机构、前瞻性或随机对照研究来进一步证实其在现实世界中的性能。