Pacific Northwest National Laboratory, Richland, WA, USA.
Pacific Northwest National Laboratory, Richland, WA, USA.
J Environ Manage. 2022 Feb 1;303:114123. doi: 10.1016/j.jenvman.2021.114123. Epub 2021 Nov 25.
Surface barriers are designed to isolate subsurface contaminants for 1000 years or longer, functionally limiting water infiltration and removing the driving force for contaminant transport to groundwater. Cost-effective monitoring is challenging because of the long design life for surface barriers, spatial limitations and finite lifetime of in situ sensors, and performance metrics related to drainage. Hence, ground-penetrating radar (GPR) and electromagnetic induction (EMI) tools were evaluated for use in performance monitoring of surface barriers. GPR and EMI were used to non-invasively interrogate the Prototype Hanford Barrier (PHB), an evapotranspiration-capillary break barrier established in 1994 at the Hanford Site, in southeastern Washington State. Both geophysical methods were evaluated for providing indirect estimates of subsurface moisture content conditions that were compared to point scale measurements from borehole neutron logs. Surveys were performed during characteristically wet and dry periods to observe a range of hydrologic states of the barrier soil. Although EMI surveys were expected to show seasonal changes associated with changes in the bulk conductivity of the barrier soil layers, the effectiveness of the method was limited by the effects of metallic infrastructure embedded in the barrier. GPR estimates of volumetric water content were typically within 2-3% of the highest water contents from neutron probe measurements for both wet and dry periods, providing reasonable estimates of water content. Given that PHB monitoring data over the past 25 years has demonstrated its success in limiting deep drainage, GPR was found to be a cost-effective method for demonstrating continued barrier performance, with a greater capacity to quantify moisture content distributions over much larger areas relative to point measurements.
表面屏障旨在隔离地下污染物 1000 年或更长时间,从功能上限制水的渗透,并消除污染物向地下水迁移的驱动力。由于表面屏障的设计寿命长、空间限制以及原位传感器的有限寿命,以及与排水相关的性能指标,因此具有成本效益的监测具有挑战性。因此,评估了探地雷达(GPR)和电磁感应(EMI)工具在表面屏障性能监测中的应用。GPR 和 EMI 用于非侵入性探测原型汉福德屏障(PHB),这是 1994 年在华盛顿州东南部的汉福德场址建立的蒸发蒸腾-毛细阻断屏障。这两种地球物理方法都用于提供对地下水分含量条件的间接估计,这些估计与来自钻孔中子测井的点尺度测量值进行了比较。在典型的湿期和干期进行了调查,以观察屏障土壤的一系列水文状态。尽管 EMI 调查预计会显示与屏障土壤层的整体电导率变化相关的季节性变化,但该方法的有效性受到嵌入屏障中的金属基础设施的影响限制。GPR 对体积含水量的估计通常与中子探针测量的最高含水量相差 2-3%,对于湿期和干期都提供了合理的含水量估计。鉴于过去 25 年的 PHB 监测数据证明了其在限制深层排水方面的成功,因此发现 GPR 是一种具有成本效益的方法,可以证明屏障性能的持续,与点测量相比,它具有更大的能力来量化更大区域内的水分含量分布。