Grover Sanya, Fitzpatrick Aoife, Azim Farah Tabassum, Ariza-Vega Patrocinio, Bellwood Paule, Burns Jane, Burton Elissa, Fleig Lena, Clemson Lindy, Hoppmann Christiane A, Madden Kenneth M, Price Morgan, Langford Dolores, Ashe Maureen C
McMaster University, Hamilton, Canada.
National University of Ireland, Galway, Ireland.
Patient Educ Couns. 2022 Jul;105(7):1679-1688. doi: 10.1016/j.pec.2021.11.004. Epub 2021 Nov 16.
Patient- or person-centered care (PCC) integrates people's preferences, values, and beliefs into health decision-making. Gaps exist for defining and implementing PCC; therefore, we aimed to identify core elements of PCC and synthesize implementation facilitators and barriers.
We conducted an overview of systematic reviews (umbrella review) and included peer-reviewed literature for adults in community/primary care settings. Two reviewers independently screened at Level 1 and 2, extracted data and appraised the quality of reviews. Three reviewers conducted a thematic analysis, and we present a narrative synthesis of findings.
There were 2371 citations screened, and 10 systematic reviews included. We identified 10 PCC definitions with common elements, such as patient empowerment, patient individuality, and a biopsychosocial approach. Implementation factors focused on communication, training healthcare providers, and organizational structure.
We provide a synthesis of key PCC elements to include in a future definition, and an overview of elements to consider for implementing PCC into practice. We extend existing literature by identifying clinician empowerment and culture change at the systems-level as two future areas to prioritize to enable routine integration of PCC into practice.
Findings may be useful for researchers and or health providers delivering and evaluating PCC.
以患者或个人为中心的护理(PCC)将人们的偏好、价值观和信念纳入健康决策。在PCC的定义和实施方面存在差距;因此,我们旨在确定PCC的核心要素,并综合实施促进因素和障碍。
我们对系统评价进行了概述(伞形评价),纳入了社区/初级保健环境中针对成年人的同行评审文献。两名评审员独立进行一级和二级筛选,提取数据并评估评价的质量。三名评审员进行了主题分析,我们对研究结果进行了叙述性综合。
共筛选了2371篇引文,纳入了10篇系统评价。我们确定了10个具有共同要素的PCC定义,如患者赋权、患者个体性和生物心理社会方法。实施因素集中在沟通、培训医疗保健提供者和组织结构方面。
我们综合了关键的PCC要素,以便纳入未来的定义,并概述了将PCC付诸实践时需要考虑的要素。我们通过将临床医生赋权和系统层面的文化变革确定为未来需要优先考虑的两个领域,以实现PCC在实践中的常规整合,从而扩展了现有文献。
研究结果可能对提供和评估PCC的研究人员和健康提供者有用。