Department of Medicine, University of California, San Francisco, California, United States of America.
Department of Emergency Medicine, NYU Langone Health, New York, United States of America.
PLoS One. 2021 Dec 2;16(12):e0260467. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0260467. eCollection 2021.
Patients often do not disclose domestic violence (DV) to healthcare providers in emergency departments and other healthcare settings. Barriers to disclosure may include fears and misconceptions about whether, and under what circumstances, healthcare providers report DV to law enforcement and immigration authorities. We sought to assess undocumented Latino immigrants (UDLI), Latino legal residents/citizens (LLRC) and non-Latino legal residents/citizens (NLRC) beliefs about disclosure of DV victimization to healthcare providers and healthcare provider reporting of DV to law enforcement and immigration authorities. From 10/2018-2/2020, we conducted this survey study at two urban emergency departments (EDs) in California. Participants, enrolled by convenience sampling, responded to survey questions adapted from a previously published survey instrument that was developed to assess undocumented immigrant fears of accessing ED care. Our primary outcomes were the proportions of UDLI, LLRC and NLRC who knew of someone who had experienced DV in the past year, whether these DV victims were afraid to access ED care, reasons DV victims were afraid to access ED care, and rates of misconceptions (defined according to current California law) about the consequences of disclosing DV to healthcare providers. Of 667 patients approached, 531 (80%) agreed to participate: 32% UDLI, 33% LLRC, and 35% NLRC. Of the 27.5% of respondents who knew someone who experienced DV in the past year, 46% stated that the DV victim was afraid to seek ED care; there was no significant difference in this rate between groups. The most common fears reported as barriers to disclosure were fear the doctor would report DV to police (31%) and fear that the person perpetrating DV would find out about the disclosure (30.3%). Contrary to our hypothesis, UDLI had lower rates of misconceptions about healthcare provider and law enforcement responses to DV disclosure than LLRC and NLRC. Fear of disclosing DV and misconceptions about the consequences of disclosure of DV to healthcare providers were common, indicating a need for provider, patient, and community education and changes that lower barriers to help-seeking.
患者在急诊科和其他医疗环境中常常不向医疗保健提供者透露家庭暴力(DV)。披露的障碍可能包括对医疗保健提供者向执法和移民当局报告 DV 的可能性和情况的恐惧和误解。我们试图评估无证拉丁裔移民(UDLI)、拉丁裔合法居民/公民(LLRC)和非拉丁裔合法居民/公民(NLRC)对向医疗保健提供者披露 DV 受害情况以及医疗保健提供者向执法和移民当局报告 DV 的看法。从 2018 年 10 月至 2020 年 2 月,我们在加利福尼亚州的两个城市急诊科(ED)进行了这项调查研究。通过便利抽样招募的参与者回答了从以前发表的调查工具改编而来的调查问题,该工具旨在评估无证移民对获得 ED 护理的恐惧。我们的主要结果是 UDLI、LLRC 和 NLRC 中知道过去一年有人经历过 DV 的人的比例,这些 DV 受害者是否害怕获得 ED 护理,DV 受害者害怕获得 ED 护理的原因,以及对向医疗保健提供者披露 DV 的后果的误解率(根据当前加利福尼亚州法律定义)。在接触的 667 名患者中,有 531 名(80%)同意参与:32%的 UDLI,33%的 LLRC,35%的 NLRC。在过去一年中知道有人经历过 DV 的受访者中,有 27.5%的人表示 DV 受害者害怕寻求 ED 护理;各组之间的这种比率没有显着差异。报告的阻碍披露的最常见恐惧是担心医生会向警方报告 DV(31%)和担心施暴者会发现披露的情况(30.3%)。与我们的假设相反,UDLI 对医疗保健提供者和执法部门对 DV 披露的反应的误解率低于 LLRC 和 NLRC。向医疗保健提供者披露 DV 的恐惧和对向医疗保健提供者披露 DV 的后果的误解很常见,这表明需要对提供者、患者和社区进行教育,并进行改革以降低寻求帮助的障碍。