Riemann Georg, Chrispijn Melissa, Weisscher Nadine, Regeer Eline, Kupka Ralph W
Department of Applied Psychology, Saxion University of Applied Sciences, Deventer, Netherlands.
Dimence Mental Health, Center for Bipolar Disorders, Deventer, Netherlands.
Front Psychiatry. 2021 Nov 11;12:725381. doi: 10.3389/fpsyt.2021.725381. eCollection 2021.
Pharmacotherapy is a cornerstone in bipolar disorder (BD) treatment whereas borderline personality disorder (BPD) is treated primarily with psychotherapy. Given the overlap in symptomatology, patients with BD may benefit from psychotherapy designed for BPD. This paper reports the findings of a non-controlled open feasibility study of STEPPS training in patients with BD and borderline personality features (BPF). Outpatients with BD were screened for BPD, and if positive interviewed with SCID-II. Patients with at least three BPF, always including impulsivity and anger burst, were included in the intervention study. Severity of BD and BPD and quality of life were assessed. Descriptive statistics were performed. Of 111 patients with BD 49.5% also screened positive on BPD according to PDQ-4+, and 52.3% of these had BPD according to SCID-II. Very few participants entered the intervention study, and only nine patients completed STEPPS. Descriptive statistics showed improvement on all outcome variables post treatment, but no longer at 6-month follow up. We reflect on the potential reasons for the failed inclusion. Features of BPD were highly prevalent in patients with BD. Still, recruiting patients for a psychological treatment originally designed for BPD proved to be difficult. Feedback of participants suggests that the association of STEPPS with "borderline" had an aversive effect, which may have caused limited inclusion for screening and subsequent drop-out for the treatment. Therefore, STEPPS should be adapted for BD to be an acceptable treatment option. www.ClinicalTrials.gov/3856, identifier: NTR4016.
药物治疗是双相情感障碍(BD)治疗的基石,而边缘型人格障碍(BPD)主要通过心理治疗。鉴于症状学上的重叠,BD患者可能从为BPD设计的心理治疗中获益。本文报告了一项针对有BD和边缘型人格特征(BPF)患者的STEPPS训练的非对照开放性可行性研究结果。对BD门诊患者进行BPD筛查,若呈阳性则用SCID-II进行访谈。至少有三种BPF(始终包括冲动性和愤怒爆发)的患者被纳入干预研究。评估了BD和BPD的严重程度以及生活质量。进行了描述性统计。在111名BD患者中,根据PDQ-4+,49.5%的患者BPD筛查也呈阳性,其中52.3%的患者根据SCID-II诊断为BPD。很少有参与者进入干预研究,只有9名患者完成了STEPPS。描述性统计显示治疗后所有结局变量均有改善,但在6个月随访时不再如此。我们思考了纳入失败的潜在原因。BPD特征在BD患者中非常普遍。然而,事实证明,招募原本为BPD设计的心理治疗患者很困难。参与者的反馈表明,STEPPS与“边缘型”的关联产生了厌恶效应,这可能导致筛查时纳入有限以及治疗过程中后续退出。因此,STEPPS应针对BD进行调整,以成为一个可接受的治疗选择。www.ClinicalTrials.gov/3856,标识符:NTR4016。