Faculty of Science and Engineering, University of Wolverhampton, Wolverhampton, WV1 1LY, UK.
Department of Health Sciences, Lund University, 221 85, Lund, Sweden.
Sci Rep. 2021 Dec 7;11(1):23550. doi: 10.1038/s41598-021-02813-y.
Parkinson's disease (PD) is characterized by rigidity, akinesia, postural instability and tremor. Deep brain stimulation (DBS) of the subthalamic nucleus (STN) reduces tremor but the effects on postural instability are inconsistent. Another component of postural control is the postural strategy, traditionally referred to as the ankle or hip strategy, which is determined by the coupling between the joint motions of the body. We aimed to determine whether DBS STN and vision (eyes open vs. eyes closed) affect the postural strategy in PD in quiet stance or during balance perturbations. Linear motion was recorded from the knee, hip, shoulder and head in 10 patients with idiopathic PD with DBS STN (after withdrawal of other anti-PD medication), 25 younger adult controls and 17 older adult controls. Correlation analyses were performed on anterior-posterior linear motion data to determine the coupling between the four positions measured. All participants were asked to stand for a 30 s period of quiet stance and a 200 s period of calf vibration. The 200 s vibration period was subdivided into four 50 s periods to study adaptation between the first vibration period (30-80 s) and the last vibration period (180-230 s). Movement was recorded in patients with PD with DBS ON and DBS OFF, and all participants were investigated with eyes closed and eyes open. DBS settings were randomized and double-blindly programmed. Patients with PD had greater coupling of the body compared to old and young controls during balance perturbations (p ≤ 0.046). Controls adopted a strategy with greater flexibility, particularly using the knee as a point of pivot, whereas patients with PD adopted an ankle strategy, i.e., they used the ankle as the point of pivot. There was higher flexibility in patients with PD with DBS ON and eyes open compared to DBS OFF and eyes closed (p ≤ 0.011). During balance perturbations, controls quickly adopted a new strategy that they retained throughout the test, but patients with PD were slower to adapt. Patients with PD further increased the coupling between segmental movement during balance perturbations with DBS ON but retained a high level of coupling with DBS OFF throughout balance perturbations. The ankle strategy during balance perturbations in patients with PD was most evident with DBS OFF and eyes closed. The increased coupling with balance perturbations implies a mechanism to reduce complexity at a cost of exerting more energy. Strategic alterations of posture were altered by DBS in patients with PD and were delayed. Our findings therefore show that DBS does not fully compensate for disease-related effects on posture.
帕金森病(PD)的特征是僵硬、运动迟缓、姿势不稳和震颤。丘脑底核(STN)的深部脑刺激(DBS)可减轻震颤,但对姿势不稳的影响不一致。姿势控制的另一个组成部分是姿势策略,传统上称为踝关节或髋关节策略,它由身体关节运动的耦合决定。我们旨在确定 DBS STN 和视觉(睁眼与闭眼)是否会影响 PD 患者在安静站立或平衡干扰期间的姿势策略。10 名接受 DBS STN 治疗的特发性 PD 患者(停用其他抗 PD 药物后)、25 名年轻成年对照者和 17 名老年成年对照者的膝关节、髋关节、肩部和头部进行线性运动记录。对四个位置的前-后线性运动数据进行相关分析,以确定测量位置之间的耦合。所有参与者均被要求站立 30 秒的安静站立期和 200 秒的小腿振动期。200 秒的振动期被分为四个 50 秒的时期,以研究第一个振动期(30-80 秒)和最后一个振动期(180-230 秒)之间的适应。在 DBS ON 和 DBS OFF 下记录 PD 患者的运动,所有参与者闭眼和睁眼进行研究。DBS 设置随机且双盲编程。与老年和年轻对照组相比,PD 患者在平衡干扰期间的身体耦合更大(p≤0.046)。对照组采用灵活性更大的策略,特别是使用膝关节作为枢轴点,而 PD 患者采用踝关节策略,即使用踝关节作为枢轴点。与 DBS OFF 和闭眼相比,DBS ON 和睁眼时 PD 患者的灵活性更高(p≤0.011)。在平衡干扰期间,对照组迅速采用了一种新策略,并在整个测试中保持该策略,但 PD 患者适应较慢。与 DBS OFF 相比,PD 患者在 DBS ON 期间进一步增加了平衡干扰期间节段运动的耦合,但在整个平衡干扰期间仍保持高耦合。PD 患者在平衡干扰期间的踝关节策略在 DBS OFF 和闭眼时最为明显。平衡干扰时耦合的增加意味着一种降低复杂性的机制,但代价是需要消耗更多的能量。PD 患者的姿势策略改变受 DBS 影响,且延迟。因此,我们的研究结果表明,DBS 不能完全补偿与疾病相关的对姿势的影响。