University of Toronto, Canada.
J Hist Med Allied Sci. 2022 Feb 7;77(1):24-47. doi: 10.1093/jhmas/jrab044.
The Japanese Imperial Army Unit 731's Biological Warfare (BW) research program committed atrocious crimes against humanity in their pursuit of biological weapons development during the Second World War. Due to an American cover-up, the details behind Unit 731's human experimentation were slow to be revealed. The recent literature discloses the gruesome details of the experiments but characterizes the human trials as crude in nature. Further, there is a lack of clarity as to how human trial results were extrapolated for use in real world missions. Through an examination of testimony from the Soviet Union's Khabarovsk War Crime Trials, this paper argues that Unit 731's inoculation and airborne warfare experiments on prisoners of war were scientifically rigorous. The scientific method is used as the basis against which the scientific rigor of the experiments is tested. The paper reveals that the successes and failures of the human trials were extrapolated to BW missions during the Sino-Japanese war. American researchers' expectations of BW data were fulfilled, thus paving the way for an immunity deal. Ethical standards in medicine before WWII were not well established, but wartime medical practices and experimentation reveal the context in which the pursuit of scientific knowledge has no boundaries.
二战期间,日本帝国陆军第 731 部队在追求生物武器开发的过程中犯下了令人发指的反人类罪行。由于美国的掩盖,第 731 部队人体实验的细节迟迟未被揭露。最近的文献揭示了这些实验的可怕细节,但将人体试验定性为粗糙。此外,如何将人体试验结果推断用于实际任务尚不清楚。通过对苏联哈巴罗夫斯克战争罪审判证词的审查,本文认为,第 731 部队对战俘进行的接种和空气传播战争实验具有科学严谨性。科学方法被用作检验实验科学性的基础。本文揭示了人体试验的成败被推断用于中日战争中的生物战任务。美国研究人员对生物战数据的预期得到了满足,从而为豁免协议铺平了道路。二战前医学领域的伦理标准尚未得到很好的建立,但战时的医疗实践和实验揭示了追求科学知识没有界限的背景。