Gesler W
Soc Sci Med. 1986;23(10):963-73. doi: 10.1016/0277-9536(86)90253-4.
This paper is a review of how geographers and others have used spatial analysis to study disease and health care delivery patterns. Point, line, area and surface patterns, as well as map comparisons and relative spaces are discussed. Problems encountered in applying spatial analytic techniques in medical geography are pointed out. The paper is intended to stimulate discussion about where medical geography can and should go in this area of study. Point pattern techniques include standard distance, standard deviational ellipses, gradient analysis and space and space-time clustering. Line methods include random walks, vectors and graph theory or network analysis. Under areas, location quotients, standardized mortality ratios, Poisson probabilities, space and space-time clustering, autocorrelation measures and hierarchical clustering are discussed. Surface techniques mentioned are isolines and trend surfaces. For map comparisons, Lorenz curves, coefficients of areal correspondence and correlation coefficients have been used. Case-control matching, acquaintance networks, multidimensional scaling and cluster analysis are examples of methods that are based on relative or non-metric spaces. The review gives rise to the discussion of several general points: problems encountered in spatial analysis, theory building and verification, the appropriate role of technique and computer use. Some suggestions are made for further use of spatial analytic techniques in medical geography: Monte Carlo simulation of point patterns, network analysis to study referral systems and health care for pastoralists, geographic information systems to assess environmental risk, difference mapping for disease and risk factor map comparisons and multidimensional scaling to measure social distance.
本文综述了地理学家及其他人员如何运用空间分析来研究疾病及医疗服务提供模式。文中讨论了点、线、面模式,以及地图比较和相对空间。指出了在医学地理学中应用空间分析技术时遇到的问题。本文旨在激发关于医学地理学在该研究领域能够且应该如何发展的讨论。点模式技术包括标准距离、标准偏差椭圆、梯度分析以及空间和时空聚类。线方法包括随机游走、向量以及图论或网络分析。在区域方面,讨论了区位商、标准化死亡率、泊松概率、空间和时空聚类、自相关测度以及层次聚类。提及的面技术是等值线和趋势面。对于地图比较,已使用洛伦兹曲线、面积对应系数和相关系数。病例对照匹配、熟人网络、多维尺度分析和聚类分析是基于相对或非度量空间的方法示例。该综述引发了对几个一般要点的讨论:空间分析中遇到的问题、理论构建与验证、技术的恰当作用以及计算机的使用。针对在医学地理学中进一步运用空间分析技术提出了一些建议:点模式的蒙特卡罗模拟、用于研究转诊系统和牧民医疗保健的网络分析、用于评估环境风险的地理信息系统、用于疾病和风险因素地图比较的差异映射以及用于测量社会距离的多维尺度分析。