Department of Health Systems and Population Health Sciences, College of Medicine, University of Houston, Houston, TX, USA.
Humana Integrated Health System Sciences Institute, University of Houston, Houston, TX, USA.
Ann Med. 2022 Dec;54(1):98-107. doi: 10.1080/07853890.2021.2019826.
The Coronavirus Aid, Relief, and Economic Security Act led to the rapid implementation of telemedicine across health care office settings. Whether this transition to telemedicine has any impact on missed appointments is yet to be determined. This study examined the relationship between telemedicine usage and missed appointments during the COVID-19 pandemic.
This retrospective study used appointment-level data from 55 Federally Qualified Health Centre clinics in Texas between March and November 2020. To account for the nested data structure of repeated appointments within each patient, a mixed-effects multivariable logistic regression model was used to examine associations between telemedicine use and missed appointments, adjusting for patient sociodemographic characteristics, geographic classification, past medical history, and clinic characteristics. The independent variable was having a telemedicine appointment, defined as an audiovisual consultation started and finalized via a telemedicine platform. The outcome of interest was having a missed appointment (yes/no) after a scheduled and confirmed medical appointment. Results from this initial model were stratified by appointment type (in-person vs. telemedicine).
The analytic sample included 278,171 appointments for 85,413 unique patients. The overall missed appointment rate was 18%, and 25% of all appointments were telemedicine appointments. Compared to in-person visits, telemedicine visits were less likely to result in a missed appointment (OR = 0.87, < .001). Compared to Whites, Asians were less likely to have a missed appointment (OR = 0.82, < .001) while African Americans, Hispanics, and American Indians were all significantly more likely to have missed appointments (OR = 1.61, < .001; OR = 1.19, = .01; OR = 1.22, < .01, respectively). Those accessing mental health services (OR = 1.57 for in-person and 0.78 for telemedicine) and living in metropolitan areas (OR = 1.15 for in-person and 0.82 for telemedicine) were more likely to miss in-person appointments but less likely to miss telemedicine appointments. Patients with frequent medical visits or those living with chronic diseases were more likely to miss in-person appointments but less likely to miss telemedicine appointments.
Telemedicine is strongly associated with fewer missed appointments. Although our findings suggest a residual lag in minority populations, specific patient populations, including those with frequent prior visits or chronic conditions, those seeking mental health services, and those living in metropolitan areas were less likely to miss telemedicine appointments than in-person visits. These findings highlight how telemedicine can enable effective and accessible care by reducing missed healthcare appointments.KEY MESSAGESTelemedicine was associated with 13% lower odds of missed appointments.Patients with frequent medical visits or those living with chronic diseases were less likely to miss telemedicine appointments but more likely to miss in-person appointments.Patients seeking mental health services were less likely to miss telemedicine appointments but more likely to miss in-person appointments.Similarly, those living in metropolitan areas were less likely to miss telemedicine appointments but more likely to miss in-person appointments.
《冠状病毒援助、救济和经济安全法案》导致远程医疗在医疗办公环境中迅速普及。这种向远程医疗的转变是否会导致预约的取消还有待确定。本研究旨在调查 COVID-19 大流行期间远程医疗使用与预约取消之间的关系。
本回顾性研究使用了德克萨斯州 55 家联邦合格医疗中心诊所 2020 年 3 月至 11 月期间的预约级别数据。为了考虑到每个患者内重复预约的嵌套数据结构,使用混合效应多变量逻辑回归模型来检验远程医疗使用与预约取消之间的关联,同时调整了患者的社会人口特征、地理分类、既往病史和诊所特征。自变量为进行了远程医疗预约,定义为通过远程医疗平台开始并完成的视听咨询。感兴趣的结果是在安排和确认的医疗预约后出现预约取消(是/否)。对这一初始模型的结果按预约类型(现场预约与远程医疗预约)进行分层。
分析样本包括 278171 次预约,涉及 85413 名患者。总体预约取消率为 18%,所有预约中有 25%是远程医疗预约。与现场就诊相比,远程医疗就诊预约取消的可能性更低(OR=0.87,<.001)。与白人相比,亚洲人预约取消的可能性更低(OR=0.82,<.001),而非裔美国人、西班牙裔和美洲原住民预约取消的可能性显著更高(OR=1.61,<.001;OR=1.19,=0.01;OR=1.22,<.01)。接受心理健康服务的患者(现场就诊的 OR=1.57,远程医疗的 OR=0.78)和居住在大都市地区的患者(现场就诊的 OR=1.15,远程医疗的 OR=0.82)更有可能错过现场就诊预约,但不太可能错过远程医疗预约。就诊频繁或患有慢性病的患者更有可能错过现场就诊预约,但不太可能错过远程医疗预约。
远程医疗与较少的预约取消密切相关。尽管我们的研究结果表明少数民族人口存在滞后,但特定的患者群体,包括就诊频繁或患有慢性病、寻求心理健康服务以及居住在大都市地区的患者,不太可能错过远程医疗预约,而不是现场就诊预约。这些发现强调了远程医疗如何通过减少医疗保健预约取消来实现有效和可及的护理。
关键信息
远程医疗与预约取消的可能性降低 13%有关。
就诊频繁或患有慢性病的患者不太可能错过远程医疗预约,但更有可能错过现场就诊预约。
寻求心理健康服务的患者不太可能错过远程医疗预约,但更有可能错过现场就诊预约。
同样,居住在大都市地区的患者不太可能错过远程医疗预约,但更有可能错过现场就诊预约。