Interuniversity College for Health and Development Graz, Leibnitz, Austria.
UniSA Allied Health and Human Performance, University of South Australia, Adelaide, Australia.
Physiother Theory Pract. 2023 Feb;39(2):351-368. doi: 10.1080/09593985.2021.2015812. Epub 2022 Jan 4.
Different cultures and societal structures influence the ethical experiences of physiotherapists.
The study aimed to discover and describe contextual shades of ethical situations experienced by physiotherapists in their global practice.
This paper reports the qualitative analysis of responses to an optional open question in an internationally distributed online survey (ESPI study) with 1,212 participants from 94 countries. All responses were coded to five categories describing the data's relationship to the survey list of ethical situations. Data that described new ethical situations were analyzed thematically.
Three hundred and fifty four individual responses to the optional survey question reported 400 ethical issues. Three hundred and seventy-eight of these issues were associated with the original survey questions. Twenty-two responses raised four new themes of ethical issues: lack of regulatory and/or accreditation policy and infrastructure, lack of recognition of the role and position of physiotherapists in healthcare, economic factors driving the conduct of practice, and political threats.
Local contexts and pressures of workplaces and societies in which physiotherapists practice make it almost impossible for some practitioners to comply with codes of ethics. Physiotherapists need support and preparation to respond to local affordances and the complexity, ambiguity, and sometimes messiness of ethical situations encountered in their practice.
The findings highlight the relevance of cross-cultural research in the field of physiotherapy, and the necessity of investigating and bridging the gap between professional ethics theory and practice in diverse settings.
不同的文化和社会结构影响着物理治疗师的伦理体验。
本研究旨在发现和描述物理治疗师在全球实践中所经历的伦理情境的背景差异。
本文报告了对一项国际分布的在线调查(ESPI 研究)中可选开放式问题的响应的定性分析,该调查有来自 94 个国家的 1212 名参与者。所有的回复都被编码为五个类别,描述了数据与调查伦理情境列表的关系。描述新伦理情境的数据进行了主题分析。
对可选调查问题的 354 个单独回复报告了 400 个伦理问题。其中 378 个问题与原始调查问题有关。22 个回复提出了四个新的伦理问题主题:缺乏监管和/或认证政策和基础设施、缺乏对物理治疗师在医疗保健中的角色和地位的认可、经济因素驱动实践行为以及政治威胁。
物理治疗师工作场所和所在社会的当地背景和压力使得一些从业者几乎不可能遵守道德规范。物理治疗师需要支持和准备,以应对当地的环境,并应对实践中遇到的伦理情境的复杂性、模糊性,有时甚至是混乱。
这些发现强调了跨文化研究在物理治疗领域的相关性,以及在不同环境中调查和弥合职业道德理论与实践之间差距的必要性。