Abdwani Reem, Al Saadoon Muna, Jaju Sanjay, Elshinawy Mohamed, Almaimani Asmaa, Wali Yasser, Khater Doaa
Departments of Child Health.
Family Medicine, College of Medicine and Health Sciences, Sultan Qaboos University.
J Pediatr Hematol Oncol. 2022 May 1;44(4):e826-e832. doi: 10.1097/MPH.0000000000002389. Epub 2022 Jan 5.
The Ministry of Health in Oman and some of Gulf regions set the cut-off age of "transfer" from child health care to adult health care at 13 years of age. Within the existing health system in this part of the world, there is paucity of evidence on the appropriate age for health care "transfer" of adolescents and young adults to adult health care. Similarly, there is lack of a structured health care "transition" program. The objective of the study is to indirectly determine the appropriateness of present cut-off age of transfer by studying readiness for transition among Omani patients suffering from chronic hematological conditions.
One hundred fifty adolescents and young adults with chronic hematological conditions were recruited from pediatric and adults clinics at Sultan Qaboos University Hospital. Participants were interviewed by a trained research assistant using the Arabic version of UNC TRxANSITION Scale to assess self-management skills and health related knowledge for transition. The score range is 0 to 10; the transition readiness of the patients is assessed as low (0 to 4), moderate (4 to 6), and high (6 to 10) respectively. The continuous variables were analyzed by parametric or nonparametric methods as appropriate. χ2 analysis was done to determine association of age groups within each sexes.
The study recruited 150 subjects (52.7% males) with 50 patients in each of the 3 age groups of 10 to 13 years (lower), 14 to 17 years (middle), and 18 to 21years (higher). The mean UNC TRxANSITION Scale scores of 5.14 (SD=1.27) in males in the total sample were significantly lower as compared with that of 5.67 (SD=1.50) in females (P=0.022). There is a steady increase in the overall median score with increase in age group, with median score of 4.42 in the lower, 5.26 in the middle and 6.81 in the higher age group (P<0.001). In section wise analysis, except for Adherence and Nutrition sections of the scale, all sections have statistically significant difference in the median scores across various age categories with lowest scores in the 10 to 13 age group and highest scores in the 18 to 21 years group. In the section related to reproduction, females had significantly higher mean ranks (31.52) and compared with 17.19 in males (P=0.001). The overall median transition score when analyzed separately for males and females across age groups showed that in the higher age group, 67% of males (P=0.008) and 90% females (P<0.001) have high transition scores compared with the other 2 groups.
Higher age was a significant predictor for transition readiness with median score being "moderate" in the lower and middle age groups, while the higher age groups scoring "high" on transition readiness. However, in the higher age group, the females (90%) showed better transition readiness than males (67%). The current age of transfer of 13 years is just at "moderate" levels. We recommend the need for establishing transition preparation program in Oman; increasing health transfer age in Oman to a cut-off age of 18 years and taking sex differences into consideration when providing interventions.
阿曼卫生部及一些海湾地区将儿童医疗保健向成人医疗保健“转移”的截止年龄设定为13岁。在世界这一地区现有的卫生系统中,关于青少年和青年向成人医疗保健进行卫生保健“转移”的合适年龄,证据匮乏。同样,也缺乏结构化的卫生保健“过渡”项目。本研究的目的是通过研究患有慢性血液疾病的阿曼患者的过渡准备情况,间接确定目前转移截止年龄的适宜性。
从苏丹卡布斯大学医院的儿科和成人诊所招募了150名患有慢性血液疾病的青少年和青年。由一名经过培训的研究助理使用阿拉伯语版的UNC TRxANSITION量表对参与者进行访谈,以评估自我管理技能和与过渡相关的健康知识。分数范围为0至10分;患者的过渡准备情况分别评估为低(0至4分)、中(4至6分)和高(6至10分)。连续变量根据情况采用参数或非参数方法进行分析。进行χ2分析以确定各性别内年龄组之间的关联。
该研究招募了150名受试者(52.7%为男性),在10至13岁(低龄组)、14至17岁(中龄组)和18至21岁(高龄组)这3个年龄组中各有50名患者。总样本中男性的UNC TRxANSITION量表平均得分5.14(标准差=1.27)显著低于女性的5.67(标准差=1.50)(P=0.022)。随着年龄组的增加,总体中位数得分稳步上升,低龄组中位数得分为4.42,中龄组为5.26,高龄组为6.81(P<0.001)。在按部分分析中,除量表的依从性和营养部分外,所有部分在不同年龄类别中的中位数得分均有统计学显著差异,10至13岁年龄组得分最低,18至21岁组得分最高。在与生殖相关的部分,女性的平均秩次(31.52)显著高于男性的17.19(P=0.001)。按年龄组分别对男性和女性进行分析时,总体中位数过渡得分显示,在高龄组中,67%的男性(P=0.008)和90%的女性(P<0.001)的过渡得分较高,与其他两组相比。
较高年龄是过渡准备情况的重要预测因素,低龄组和中龄组的中位数得分“中等”,而高龄组在过渡准备方面得分“高”。然而,在高龄组中,女性(90%)的过渡准备情况优于男性(67%)。目前13岁的转移年龄仅处于“中等”水平。我们建议阿曼需要建立过渡准备项目;将阿曼的卫生转移年龄提高到18岁的截止年龄,并在提供干预措施时考虑性别差异。