Department of Biochemistry and Biophysics, University of California, San Francisco (UCSF), San Francisco, California, USA.
FEBS Lett. 2022 Jan;596(2):149-159. doi: 10.1002/1873-3468.14272. Epub 2022 Jan 10.
The COVID-19 pandemic has revealed that a shockingly large fraction of the public is willing to ignore scientific judgements on issues such a vaccines and mask wearing. For far too many, scientific findings are viewed as what scientists believe, rather than as the product of an elaborate community process that produces reliable knowledge. This widespread misunderstanding should serve as a wake-up call for scientists, clearly demonstrating that the standard way that we teach science - as a large collection of "facts" that scientists have discovered about the world - needs major change. Three more ambitious and important goals for science education at all levels are outlined. In order of increasing difficulty, these are: (1) to provide all adults with an ability to investigate scientific problems as scientists do, using logic, experiment, and evidence; (2) to provide all adults with an understanding of how the scientific enterprise works - and why they should therefore trust the consensus judgements of science on issues like smoking, vaccination, and climate change; and (3) to provide all adults with the habit of solving their everyday problems as scientists do, using logic, experiment, and evidence. Although examples exist for attaining all of these goals, extensive education research will be needed to discover how best to teach the last two. I argue that such an effort is urgent, and that it can best begin by focusing on the introductory courses in biology and other science disciplines at the university level.
新冠疫情大流行表明,相当一部分公众愿意无视疫苗接种和戴口罩等问题上的科学判断。对许多人来说,科学发现被视为科学家的信仰,而不是经过精心设计的社区过程的产物,这个过程产生了可靠的知识。这种广泛的误解应该引起科学家的警觉,清楚地表明,我们教授科学的标准方式——作为科学家发现的关于世界的大量“事实”——需要重大改变。在各个层面上,科学教育有三个更具野心和重要的目标。按难度递增的顺序排列,这些目标是:(1)使所有成年人都能够像科学家一样运用逻辑、实验和证据来调查科学问题;(2)使所有成年人都了解科学事业的运作方式——以及为什么他们应该信任科学界在吸烟、接种疫苗和气候变化等问题上的共识判断;(3)使所有成年人都养成像科学家一样运用逻辑、实验和证据来解决日常问题的习惯。虽然实现所有这些目标的例子都存在,但需要进行广泛的教育研究,以发现如何最好地教授后两个目标。我认为,这样的努力是紧迫的,可以从关注大学水平的生物学和其他科学学科的入门课程开始。