School of Computing, Gachon University, Seongnam-si, Republic of Korea.
J Med Internet Res. 2022 Jan 28;24(1):e30600. doi: 10.2196/30600.
A critical component of disaster preparedness in hospitals is experiential education and training of health care professionals. A live drill is a well-established, effective training approach, but cost restraints and logistic constraints make clinical implementation challenging, and training opportunities with live drills may be severely limited. Virtual reality simulation (VRS) technology may offer a viable training alternative with its inherent features of reproducibility, just-in-time training, and repeatability.
This integrated review examines the scientific evidence pertaining to the effectiveness of VRS and its practical usefulness in training health care professionals for in-hospital disaster preparedness.
A well-known 4-stage methodology was used for the integrated review process. It consisted of problem identification, a literature search and inclusion criteria determination, 2-stage validation and analysis of searched studies, and presentation of findings. A search of diverse publication repositories was performed. They included Web of Science (WOS), PubMed (PMD), and Embase (EMB).
The integrated review process resulted in 12 studies being included. Principle findings identified 3 major capabilities of VRS: (1) to realistically simulate the clinical environment and medical practices related to different disaster scenarios, (2) to develop learning effects on increased confidence and enhanced knowledge acquisition, and (3) to enable cost-effective implementation of training programs.
The findings from the integrated review suggested that VRS could be a competitive, cost-effective adjunct to existing training approaches. Although the findings demonstrated the applicability of VRS to different training scenarios, these do not entirely cover all disaster scenarios that could happen in hospitals. This integrated review expects that the recent advances of VR technologies can be 1 of the catalysts to enable the wider adoption of VRS training on challenging clinical scenarios that require sophisticated modeling and environment depiction.
医院灾难准备工作的一个关键组成部分是对医疗保健专业人员进行体验式教育和培训。现场演练是一种成熟且有效的培训方法,但成本限制和物流限制使得临床实施具有挑战性,并且现场演练的培训机会可能受到严重限制。虚拟现实模拟 (VRS) 技术具有可重现性、即时培训和可重复性等固有特点,可能提供一种可行的替代培训方法。
本综合评价研究考察了 VRS 在培训医院灾难准备方面的医疗保健专业人员的有效性及其实际用途的科学证据。
使用知名的 4 阶段方法进行综合评价过程。它包括问题识别、文献搜索和纳入标准确定、2 阶段验证和搜索研究分析以及结果呈现。对多个出版物存储库进行了搜索。它们包括 Web of Science (WOS)、PubMed (PMD) 和 Embase (EMB)。
综合评价过程共纳入 12 项研究。主要发现确定了 VRS 的 3 个主要功能:(1)真实模拟与不同灾难场景相关的临床环境和医疗实践,(2)在增强信心和增强知识获取方面发展学习效果,以及 (3)实现培训计划的成本效益。
综合评价的结果表明,VRS 可以作为现有培训方法的一种具有竞争力且具有成本效益的补充。尽管研究结果表明 VRS 适用于不同的培训场景,但这些场景并不能完全涵盖医院中可能发生的所有灾难场景。本综合评价预计,VR 技术的最新进展可以成为推动更广泛采用 VRS 培训的催化剂之一,用于需要复杂建模和环境描绘的具有挑战性的临床场景。