Discipline of Medical Radiation Science, Curtin Medical School, Curtin University, 6102 Perth, Australia.
Curtin Health Innovation Research Institute (CHIRI), Faculty of Health Sciences, Curtin University, 6102 Perth, Australia.
Rev Cardiovasc Med. 2022 Jan 17;23(1):22. doi: 10.31083/j.rcm2301022.
BACKGROUND: The long-term effect of three-dimensional printed heart model (3DPHM) on knowledge acquisition of congenital heart disease (CHD) remains unknown. This prospective cohort study aims to investigate the role of 3DPHM in improving immediate knowledge gain and long-term knowledge retention on CHD among the medical students. METHODS: Fifty-three second and third year medical students were assigned into two groups to compare their immediate knowledge acquisition and knowledge retention after an education session on anatomy and pathophysiology of CHD. During the 1.5 hour-long education session, both the control (n = 25) and study groups (n = 28) had access to identical teaching materials: digital 3D heart models, 2D diagrams, and medical images, except for 3DPHM which were only used in the study group. The immediate knowledge gain was assessed via an online quiz, whereas the long-term knowledge retention was assessed using another quiz in 6-weeks' time post-intervention. A survey was also conducted to evaluate the participants' learning experience. RESULTS: There is no significant difference in the immediate knowledge acquisition and long-term knowledge retention between the groups (U = 272, = 0.16 and r = -0.143, = 0.15 respectively). Majority of the students (96% in control group and 85% in 3DPHM group) responded that the 3DPHM would have/had improved their learning experience. Despite that, there is no significant difference in the self-perceived knowledge improvement between the groups. CONCLUSIONS: This study concludes that the 3DPHM do not significantly improve both immediate knowledge acquisition and knowledge retention among the medical students. However, further research with larger sample size, as well as categorizing the type of questions in the quiz, is needed to better assess the role of 3DPHM in different educational components.
背景:三维打印心脏模型(3DPHM)对先天性心脏病(CHD)知识获取的长期影响尚不清楚。本前瞻性队列研究旨在探讨 3DPHM 在提高医学生对 CHD 的即时知识获取和长期知识保留方面的作用。
方法:将 53 名二、三年级医学生分为两组,比较他们在接受 CHD 解剖学和病理生理学教育课程后的即时知识获取和知识保留情况。在 1.5 小时的教育课程中,对照组(n=25)和研究组(n=28)都可以使用相同的教学材料:数字 3D 心脏模型、2D 图和医学图像,除了研究组使用 3DPHM。即时知识获取通过在线测验进行评估,而长期知识保留则在干预后 6 周使用另一个测验进行评估。还进行了一项调查,以评估参与者的学习体验。
结果:两组之间即时知识获取和长期知识保留没有显著差异(U=272,Z=0.16 和 r=-0.143,Z=0.15)。大多数学生(对照组 96%,3DPHM 组 85%)表示,3DPHM 会/已经改善了他们的学习体验。尽管如此,两组之间自我感知的知识提高没有显著差异。
结论:本研究得出结论,3DPHM 并没有显著提高医学生的即时知识获取和知识保留。然而,需要进行更大样本量的研究,以及对测验中的问题类型进行分类,以更好地评估 3DPHM 在不同教育环节中的作用。
Rev Cardiovasc Med. 2022-1-17
Biomolecules. 2021-6-14
Front Bioeng Biotechnol. 2024-8-2
Front Bioeng Biotechnol. 2023-2-20
Micromachines (Basel). 2023-2-16
Children (Basel). 2023-2-7
Biomolecules. 2022-10-24
Micromachines (Basel). 2022-9-22