Cohen M D, Siddiqui A, Weetman R, Provisor A, Coates T
Radiology. 1986 Feb;158(2):499-505. doi: 10.1148/radiology.158.2.3510447.
If costs of medical care are to be reduced, the choice of which imaging modality to use must be made as carefully as possible. This study was done to show how radiological modalities were used to evaluate patients with Hodgkin disease and non-Hodgkin lymphoma. We kept a record of every radiological study performed on 66 children with both diseases seen in the past 6 1/3 years. The results of these studies were analyzed to see which areas of the body were studied, which imaging modality was used, how frequently the studies were repeated, and how frequently the studies gave abnormal results. Our findings disclosed that radiological studies have been appropriately performed in anatomic regions of the body in which disease is present. New imaging modalities have been introduced, and the use of some of the older modalities has been decreased. With some modalities, such as skeletal survey, liver/spleen scan, whole-lung tomography, contrast studies of the bowel, and excretory urography, utilization is higher than it ought to be in view of the fact that the yield of positive results is low and the information is obtainable in many cases from other more sensitive procedures. These studies should not be performed as a routine on initial evaluation or follow-up of all patients with Hodgkin or non-Hodgkin lymphomas. On initial presentation all patients should undergo chest radiography and CT scanning of both chest and abdomen. A problem area is that the timing of follow-up studies has been somewhat erratic, with some inappropriate studies particularly 3 or 4 years after diagnosis. Too many imaging procedures have probably been done in follow-up of our patients.
若要降低医疗成本,必须尽可能谨慎地选择使用何种成像方式。本研究旨在展示放射学成像方式如何用于评估霍奇金病和非霍奇金淋巴瘤患者。我们记录了过去6又1/3年里对66例患有这两种疾病的儿童所进行的每一项放射学检查。对这些检查结果进行分析,以了解身体的哪些部位接受了检查、使用了何种成像方式、检查重复的频率以及检查出现异常结果的频率。我们的研究结果表明,放射学检查已在存在疾病的身体解剖区域得到合理实施。新的成像方式已被引入,一些较旧方式的使用有所减少。对于某些方式,如骨骼检查、肝脏/脾脏扫描、全肺断层扫描、肠道造影检查和排泄性尿路造影,鉴于阳性结果的检出率较低且在许多情况下可通过其他更敏感的检查获得相关信息,其使用率却高于应有的水平。在对所有霍奇金或非霍奇金淋巴瘤患者进行初始评估或随访时,不应将这些检查作为常规项目。在初次就诊时,所有患者均应接受胸部X线摄影以及胸部和腹部的CT扫描。一个问题是随访检查的时间安排有些不规律,在诊断后3年或4年时存在一些不恰当的检查。在对我们的患者进行随访时,可能进行了过多的成像检查。