Department of Colorectal Surgery, Addenbrookes Hospital, Cambridge University Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust, Cambridge, UK.
Department of Surgery, University of Cambridge, Cambridge, UK.
J Robot Surg. 2022 Dec;16(6):1347-1354. doi: 10.1007/s11701-021-01358-6. Epub 2022 Feb 2.
This international study aimed to understand, from the perspective of surgeons, their experience of performing minimal access surgery (MAS), to explore causes of discomfort while operating and the impact of poor ergonomics on surgeon welfare and career longevity across different specialties and techniques. A quantitative online survey was conducted in Germany, the UK and the USA from March to April 2019. The survey comprised 17 questions across four categories: demographics, intraoperative discomfort, effects on performance and anticipated consequences. In total, 462 surgeons completed the survey. Overall, 402 (87.0%) surgeons reported experiencing discomfort while operating at least 'sometimes'. The peak professional performance age was perceived to be 45-49 years by 30.7% of surgeons, 50-54 by 26.4% and older than 55 by 10.1%. 86 (18.6%) surgeons felt it likely they would consider early retirement, of whom 83 were experiencing discomfort. Our findings highlight the continued unmet needs of surgeons performing MAS, with the overwhelming majority experiencing discomfort, frequently in the back, neck and shoulders, and many likely to consider early retirement consequently. Innovative solutions are needed to alleviate this physical burden and, in turn, prevent economic and societal impacts on healthcare systems resulting from MAS limiting surgeon longevity.
这项国际研究旨在从外科医生的角度了解他们进行微创外科手术 (MAS) 的经验,探索手术时不适的原因,以及不良人体工程学对不同专业和技术的外科医生福利和职业寿命的影响。2019 年 3 月至 4 月,在德国、英国和美国进行了一项定量在线调查。该调查包括四个类别的 17 个问题:人口统计学、术中不适、对性能的影响和预期后果。共有 462 名外科医生完成了调查。总的来说,402 名(87.0%)外科医生报告说在手术过程中至少“有时”感到不适。30.7%的外科医生认为他们的专业表现高峰期在 45-49 岁,26.4%的外科医生认为在 50-54 岁,10.1%的外科医生认为在 55 岁以上。86 名(18.6%)外科医生认为他们很可能会考虑提前退休,其中 83 名感到不适。我们的研究结果强调了进行 MAS 的外科医生持续存在的未满足需求,绝大多数外科医生感到不适,通常是在背部、颈部和肩部,许多人因此可能会考虑提前退休。需要创新的解决方案来减轻这种身体负担,并防止 MAS 限制外科医生寿命对医疗保健系统造成的经济和社会影响。