Nalugwa Talemwa, Handley Margaret, Shete Priya, Ojok Christopher, Nantale Mariam, Reza Tania, Katamba Achilles, Cattamanchi Adithya, Ackerman Sara
Department of Medicine, School of Medicine, Makerere University College of Health Sciences, Kampala, Uganda.
Uganda Tuberculosis Implementation Research Consortium, Kampala, Uganda.
Implement Sci Commun. 2022 Feb 2;3(1):9. doi: 10.1186/s43058-022-00260-y.
Newer molecular testing platforms are now available for deployment at lower-level community health centers. There are limited data on facility- and health worker-level factors that would promote successful adoption of such platforms for rapid tuberculosis (TB) testing and treatment initiation. Our study aimed to assess readiness to implement onsite molecular testing at community health centers in Uganda, a high TB burden country in sub-Saharan Africa.
To understand implementation readiness, we conducted a qualitative assessment guided by the Consolidated Framework for Implementation Research (CFIR) at 6 community health centers in central and eastern Uganda between February and April 2018. We conducted 23 in-depth, semi-structured interviews with health workers involved in TB care at each health center to assess TB-related work practices and readiness to adopt onsite molecular testing using the GeneXpert Edge platform. Interviews were transcribed verbatim and coded for thematic analysis.
Participants (N=23) included 6 nurses/nursing assistants, 6 clinicians, 6 laboratory directors/technicians, 1 medical officer, 2 health center directors, and 2 other health workers involved in TB care. Health workers described general enthusiasm that on-site molecular testing could lead to greater efficiencies in TB diagnosis and treatment, including faster turn- around time for TB test results, lack of need for trained laboratory technicians to interpret results, and reduced need to transport sputum specimens to higher level facilities. However, health workers also expressed concerns about implementation feasibility. These included uncertainty about TB infection risk, safety risks from disposal of hazardous waste, a lack of local capacity to provide timely troubleshooting and maintenance services, and concerns about the security of GeneXpert devices and accessories. Health workers also expressed the need for backup batteries to support testing or charging when wall power is unstable.
Our study generated a nuanced understanding of modifiable contextual barriers and led to direct revisions of implementation strategies for onsite molecular testing. The findings highlight that novel diagnostics should be implemented along with health system co-interventions that address contextual barriers to their effective uptake. Pre-implementation assessment of stakeholder perspectives, collaborative work processes, and institutional contexts is essential when introducing innovative technology in complex health care settings.
新型分子检测平台现已可供在较低层级的社区卫生中心部署。关于促进成功采用此类平台进行快速结核病(TB)检测和治疗启动的机构及卫生工作者层面的因素,数据有限。我们的研究旨在评估在乌干达(撒哈拉以南非洲结核病负担较重的国家)的社区卫生中心实施现场分子检测的准备情况。
为了解实施准备情况,我们于2018年2月至4月期间,在乌干达中部和东部的6个社区卫生中心,以实施研究综合框架(CFIR)为指导进行了定性评估。我们对每个卫生中心参与结核病护理的卫生工作者进行了23次深入的半结构化访谈,以评估与结核病相关的工作实践以及使用GeneXpert Edge平台采用现场分子检测的准备情况。访谈内容逐字记录并编码进行主题分析。
参与者(N = 23)包括6名护士/护理助理、6名临床医生、6名实验室主任/技术人员、1名医务人员、2名卫生中心主任以及2名参与结核病护理的其他卫生工作者。卫生工作者表示普遍认为现场分子检测可提高结核病诊断和治疗效率,包括更快得出结核病检测结果、无需训练有素的实验室技术人员解读结果以及减少将痰标本运送到上级机构的需求。然而,卫生工作者也对实施可行性表示担忧。这些担忧包括对结核病感染风险的不确定性、有害废物处置带来的安全风险、缺乏提供及时故障排除和维护服务的当地能力,以及对GeneXpert设备及配件安全性的担忧。卫生工作者还表示需要备用电池,以便在市电不稳定时支持检测或充电。
我们的研究对可改变的背景障碍有了细致入微的理解,并直接修订了现场分子检测的实施策略。研究结果突出表明,新型诊断方法应与解决有效采用这些方法的背景障碍的卫生系统协同干预措施一同实施。在复杂的医疗环境中引入创新技术时,对利益相关者观点、协作工作流程和机构背景进行实施前评估至关重要。