School of Psychology, University of Birmingham, Edgbaston, Birmingham, B15 2TT, UK.
Sci Rep. 2022 Feb 8;12(1):2076. doi: 10.1038/s41598-022-05972-8.
Authenticating valuable objects is widely assumed to involve protracted scrutiny for detection of reproduction flaws. Yet, accurate authentication of banknotes is possible within one second of viewing, suggesting that rapid neural processes may underpin counterfeit detection. To investigate, we measured event-related brain potentials (ERPs) in response to briefly viewed genuine or forensically recovered counterfeit banknotes presented in a visual oddball counterfeit detection task. Three ERP components, P1, P3, and extended P3, were assessed for each combination of banknote type (genuine, counterfeit) and overt response ("real", "fake"). P1 amplitude was greater for oddballs, demonstrating that the initial feedforward sweep of visual processing yields the essential information for differentiating genuine from counterfeit. A similar oddball effect was found for P3. The magnitude of this P3 effect was positively correlated with behavioural counterfeit sensitivity, although the corresponding correlation for P1 was not. For the extended P3, amplitude was greatest for correctly detected counterfeits and similarly small for missed counterfeits, incorrectly and correctly categorised genuine banknotes. These results show that authentication of complex stimuli involves a cascade of neural processes that unfolds in under a second, beginning with a very rapid sensory analysis, followed by a later decision stage requiring higher level processing.
鉴别有价值的物品通常需要长时间仔细检查以发现伪造瑕疵。然而,对钞票进行准确鉴别却可以在一秒内完成,这表明快速的神经过程可能是伪造检测的基础。为了进行研究,我们在视觉异常检测任务中测量了对短暂呈现的真实或法证回收的伪造钞票的事件相关脑电位(ERP)。对于每个钞票类型(真实、伪造)和明显反应(“真实”、“伪造”)的组合,评估了三个 ERP 成分:P1、P3 和扩展 P3。P1 幅度对于异常值更大,表明视觉处理的初始前馈扫描提供了区分真实与伪造的基本信息。P3 也出现了类似的异常值效应。该 P3 效应的幅度与行为伪造敏感度呈正相关,尽管 P1 的对应相关性则不然。对于扩展 P3,幅度对于正确检测到的伪造品最大,对于错过的伪造品、正确和错误分类的真实钞票则相似较小。这些结果表明,对复杂刺激的鉴别涉及一个在不到一秒内展开的神经过程级联,从非常快速的感觉分析开始,然后是需要更高水平处理的后期决策阶段。