Centre for Research on the Epidemiology of Disasters (Cred), Institute of Health and Society, Université catholique de Louvain, Brussels, Belgium.
Glob Health Action. 2022 Dec 31;15(1):2013597. doi: 10.1080/16549716.2021.2013597.
Disasters are an increasing threat to human health, but we know little about their impact on health services, particularly in low and middle-income settings. 'Resilient hospitals' have been increasingly recognized as a cornerstone of disaster management. While various frameworks of hospital resilience exist, they emerged from pre-disaster considerations, and do not incorporate evidence from post-disaster settings.
This dissertation investigated the impact of a large-scale sudden onset disaster in a tertiary hospital in Nepal, and explored its resilience mechanisms.
This consists of an in-depth case-study combining quantitative data from routinely generated hospital records and qualitative data from semi-structured interviews with hospital staff. We used both advanced statistical methods and mixed inductive and deductive coding to analyze the data.
Most of the admitted earthquake victims required surgical interventions and long hospitalizations, considerably straining the hospital. For six weeks, the average number of daily admissions decreased. During this period, the share of injury-related admissions was particularly high, and such admissions were particularly long compared to the baseline. Admissions due to other conditions relatively decreased and were shorter. We found that the hospital's resilience was highly dependent on emerging adaptations, in addition to the pre-existing disaster plan. Individual resilience of staff also played a major role, and was influenced by senses of safety, meaningfulness, and belonging.
Hospitals should prepare resources and plan for their known disaster risks, but should also allow for a certain flexibility to innovative adaptions to emerging, unforeseen challenges. Challenges faced by hospital workers should not be undermined, and addressing them will increase hospital resilience.
灾害对人类健康构成的威胁日益严重,但我们对其对卫生服务的影响知之甚少,尤其是在中低收入国家和地区。“有韧性的医院”日益被视为灾害管理的基石。尽管存在各种医院韧性框架,但它们是在灾害发生前提出的,并未纳入灾害后环境的证据。
本论文调查了尼泊尔一家三级医院突发大规模灾害的影响,并探讨了其韧性机制。
这是一项深入的案例研究,结合了医院常规记录的定量数据和医院工作人员半结构化访谈的定性数据。我们使用了先进的统计方法以及混合归纳和演绎编码来分析数据。
大多数收治的地震伤员需要手术干预和长期住院治疗,这使医院承受了巨大压力。在六周的时间里,每日入院人数平均减少。在此期间,与损伤相关的入院人数特别高,与基线相比,这些入院时间特别长。其他疾病相关的入院人数相对减少,且时间较短。我们发现,除了预先存在的灾害计划外,医院的韧性高度依赖于新出现的适应性变化。工作人员的个体韧性也起着重要作用,并且受到安全感、意义感和归属感的影响。
医院应准备资源并规划已知的灾害风险,但也应允许有一定的灵活性,以适应新出现的、意料之外的挑战。不应忽视医院工作人员面临的挑战,解决这些挑战将提高医院的韧性。