Sethi Sumita, Dabas Ruchi, Garg Renu
Department of Ophthalmology, BPS GMC for Women, Sonepat, Haryana, India.
Department of Biochemistry, BPS GMC for Women, Sonepat, Haryana, India.
J Taibah Univ Med Sci. 2021 Nov 15;17(1):105-111. doi: 10.1016/j.jtumed.2021.10.008. eCollection 2022 Feb.
This study aims to formally evaluate near-peer-assisted learning (NPAL) for teaching clinical ophthalmology skills to second-year undergraduate medical students through their fellow medical interns.
Interns posted at the department of ophthalmology were included as tutors after an initial sensitization and assessment. Second-year undergraduate students were included as tutees. Sessions were conducted for pre-identified clinical skills in batches of 3-5 tutees each. Perceptions of tutors and tutees were captured on a 5-point Likert scale (Kirkpatrick level-1) and evaluated. Tutors were assessed by directly observed procedural skills (DOPS) and tutees by pre- and post-session scores and performance of the respective clinical skills (Kirkpatrick level-2).
A total of 21 of 24 tutors and 82 of 100 tutees responded to the evaluation questionnaire. Tutors perceived themselves as knowledgeable and useful as instructors; scores of second DOPS session significantly improved compared to the first (p = 0.001) for all clinical skills. Tutees found the NPAL sessions effective for learning clinical skills. Pre- and post-test scores significantly improved (p = 0.001), and all clinical skills were satisfactorily performed in the end-of-term exam.
NPAL was perceived as an effective teaching-learning method by both tutees and tutors, and all clinical skills were performed successfully. NPAL can serve as a useful adjunct to traditional teaching for clinical training of small groups and can help alleviate teaching pressures on already burdened clinical faculty in Indian Medical colleges.
本研究旨在通过医学实习生对本科二年级医学生进行临床眼科技能教学,从而正式评估近同伴辅助学习(NPAL)。
经过初步培训和评估后,眼科科室的实习生被纳入作为导师。本科二年级学生作为学员。针对预先确定的临床技能,每次为3至5名学员进行分组授课。通过5点李克特量表(柯克帕特里克一级)收集导师和学员的看法并进行评估。通过直接观察操作技能(DOPS)对导师进行评估,通过课前和课后成绩以及各自临床技能的表现对学员进行评估(柯克帕特里克二级)。
24名导师中有21名、100名学员中有82名回复了评估问卷。导师认为自己作为指导教师知识渊博且很有用;所有临床技能的第二次DOPS课程成绩与第一次相比有显著提高(p = 0.001)。学员们发现NPAL课程对学习临床技能有效。课前和课后成绩有显著提高(p = 0.001),并且在期末考试中所有临床技能都得到了令人满意的表现。
学员和导师都认为NPAL是一种有效的教学方法,并且所有临床技能都得到了成功展示。NPAL可以作为传统教学的有益补充,用于小组临床培训,并有助于减轻印度医学院临床教师已经沉重的教学压力。