Malabar Cancer Centre, Thalassery, Kerala, India.
Gulf J Oncolog. 2021 Sep;1(37):17-22.
Neoadjuvant chemoradiation followed by surgery is the standard of care in locally advanced rectal tumors. Better pathologic response after chemoradiation is associated with better outcomes. Pathologic response may depend on various, patient and tumor related factors. The aim of our study was to assess the pathological response using a modified Ryan scoring system and to study various factors which influence the response.
This is a retrospective study carried out at a tertiary cancer centre in India. Patient details and histopathology reports of rectal cancer patients who took neoadjuvant chemoradiation from January 2016 to December 2018 were analyzed. Demographic details, pathological response assessed by modified Ryans tumor regression grade (TRG) score and various factors which influence the pathological response were studied. Those with TRG score 0 (complete response) and1(near complete response) were grouped together as good responders and those with score 3 (partial response) and 4 (poor or no response) as poor responders. Univariate and multivariate analyses were performed using logistic regression to determine factors which influence pathologic response.
There were a total of 83 patients. Males and females were equally distributed. 43.4%(n=36) of patients had lower rectal tumors,32.5%(n=27) had midrectal tumors and 24.1%(n=20) had upper rectal tumors. 46% of patients were good responders which includes complete responders ,17% (n=14) and those with a near complete response,29% (n=24). 54% of patients were poor responders,which includes those with incomplete response,36% (n=34) and with no or poor response,18% (n=15). Among the upper rectal tumors, only 20% had good response and among the mid and lower rectal tumors 54% had good response.(p value 0.02).63% of males were good responders in comparison to 37% among females (p value 0.05).
Response to neoadjuvant chemoradiation with capecitabine in locally advanced rectal tumors in our institute is similar to the literature data with a complete response in 16.9%, near complete response in 28.9% partial response in 36.1% and no response in 18.1% of patients, according to modified Ryan score. It was found that upper rectal tumors had a poorer response when compared to mid and lower tumors and females had a poorer response compared to males.
Even though neoadjuvant chemoradiation remains the standard of care in locally advanced rectal carcinomas, its benefit in upper rectal tumors needs to be validated in larger studies.
新辅助放化疗后手术是局部晚期直肠肿瘤的标准治疗方法。放化疗后更好的病理反应与更好的结果相关。病理反应可能取决于各种患者和肿瘤相关因素。我们的研究目的是使用改良 Ryan 评分系统评估病理反应,并研究影响反应的各种因素。
这是在印度一家三级癌症中心进行的回顾性研究。分析了 2016 年 1 月至 2018 年 12 月接受新辅助放化疗的直肠癌症患者的详细病史和组织病理学报告。研究了人口统计学特征、改良 Ryan 肿瘤消退分级(TRG)评分评估的病理反应以及影响病理反应的各种因素。TRG 评分 0(完全缓解)和 1(接近完全缓解)的患者被归为“良好反应者”,而 TRG 评分 3(部分缓解)和 4(差或无反应)的患者被归为“差反应者”。使用逻辑回归进行单变量和多变量分析,以确定影响病理反应的因素。
共有 83 名患者。男性和女性的分布相当。43.4%(n=36)的患者为低位直肠肿瘤,32.5%(n=27)为中位直肠肿瘤,24.1%(n=20)为高位直肠肿瘤。46%的患者为“良好反应者”,包括完全缓解者 17%(n=14)和接近完全缓解者 29%(n=24)。54%的患者为“差反应者”,包括不完全缓解者 36%(n=34)和无反应或反应差者 18%(n=15)。在上部直肠肿瘤中,只有 20%有良好反应,而在中下部直肠肿瘤中,54%有良好反应(p 值 0.02)。与女性 37%相比,男性 63%为“良好反应者”(p 值 0.05)。
在我们的研究所中,局部晚期直肠肿瘤接受卡培他滨新辅助放化疗的反应与文献数据相似,根据改良 Ryan 评分,完全缓解率为 16.9%,接近完全缓解率为 28.9%,部分缓解率为 36.1%,无反应率为 18.1%。我们发现,与中下部直肠肿瘤相比,上部直肠肿瘤的反应较差,与男性相比,女性的反应较差。
尽管新辅助放化疗仍然是局部晚期直肠癌的标准治疗方法,但需要在更大的研究中验证其在上部直肠肿瘤中的益处。