CHU Nantes, Service de Chirurgie Infantile, PHU5, 7 quai Moncousu, 44093 Nantes, France.
Hôpital Bichat-Claude Bernard, APHP, Service de Chirurgie Orthopédique et Traumatologique, 46 Rue Henri Huchard, 75018 Paris, France.
Hand Surg Rehabil. 2022 Jun;41(3):296-304. doi: 10.1016/j.hansur.2022.02.001. Epub 2022 Feb 11.
Numerous microsurgical training techniques and materials have been developed to reduce animal use and training costs. This systematic review aimed to catalog the available microsurgery learning methods on non-living material in order to define an educational program. The PubMed database was searched for English and French articles related to the initial learning of microsurgery with inert, non-living, or digital material and containing the keywords "microsurgery", "non-living", "simulation" and "virtual reality". Among the 488 articles found, 82 were included. This work reports the main microsurgery learning supports. They were classified according to the material used: inert material, cadaveric animal tissues, human cadaver model, virtual reality, and digital technologies. The educational program proposes here is a two-step program that uses non-living material (basic and deepening) before progressing to living models. This initial learning phase teaches basic microsurgical skills (precision, tremor management, and magnification). Then, frequent home training sessions help to maintain the acquired skills. Ethical, organizational, and economic constraints limit access to animal models. Therefore, inert models seem to be ideal support for initial microsurgical learning. The multiplicity of models described makes it possible to achieve progressive learning depending on which models are available.
已经开发出许多用于减少动物使用和培训成本的显微外科训练技术和材料。本系统评价旨在对非生物材料的可用显微外科学习方法进行分类,以便定义一个教育计划。在 PubMed 数据库中搜索了与使用惰性、非生物或数字材料进行显微外科初步学习相关的英文和法文文章,并包含关键词“显微外科”、“非生物”、“模拟”和“虚拟现实”。在发现的 488 篇文章中,有 82 篇被纳入。本研究报告了主要的显微外科学习支持。根据使用的材料对其进行了分类:惰性材料、尸体动物组织、人体尸体模型、虚拟现实和数字技术。这里提出的教育计划是一个两步方案,先用非生物材料(基础和深化),然后再进展到活体模型。这个初步学习阶段教授基本的显微外科技能(精度、震颤管理和放大)。然后,频繁的家庭培训有助于保持所获得的技能。伦理、组织和经济限制限制了对动物模型的使用。因此,惰性模型似乎是初步显微外科学习的理想支持。所描述的多种模型使得可以根据可用的模型进行渐进式学习。