Vitreous Retina Macula Consultants of New York, New York, NY.
Institute of Ophthalmology Fundacion Conde de Valenciana, Mexico City, Mexico; and.
Retina. 2022 Mar 1;42(3):450-455. doi: 10.1097/IAE.0000000000003348.
To evaluate the use of a deep learning noise reduction model on swept source optical coherence tomography volumetric scans.
Three groups of images including single-line highly averaged foveal scans (averaged images), foveal B-scans from volumetric scans using no averaging (unaveraged images), and deep learning denoised versions of the latter (denoised images) were obtained. We evaluated the potential increase in the signal-to-noise ratio by evaluating the contrast-to-noise ratio of the resultant images and measured the multiscale structural similarity index to determine whether the unaveraged and denoised images held true in structure to the averaged images. We evaluated the practical effects of denoising on a popular metric of choroidal vascularity known as the choroidal vascularity index.
Ten eyes of 10 subjects with a mean age of 31 years (range 24-64 years) were evaluated. The deep choroidal contrast-to-noise ratio mean values of the averaged and denoised image groups were similar (7.06 vs. 6.81, P = 0.75), and both groups had better maximum contrast-to-noise ratio mean values (27.65 and 46.34) than the unaveraged group (14.75; P = 0.001 and P < 0.001, respectively). The mean multiscale structural similarity index of the average-denoised images was significantly higher than the one from the averaged--unaveraged images (0.85 vs. 0.61, P < 0.001). Choroidal vascularity index values from averaged and denoised images were similar (71.81 vs. 71.16, P = 0.554).
Using three different metrics, we demonstrated that the deep learning denoising model can produce high-quality images that emulate, and may exceed, the quality of highly averaged scans.
评估深度学习降噪模型在扫频源光学相干断层扫描容积扫描中的应用。
获取了三组图像,包括单一线高度平均的黄斑扫描(平均图像)、使用无平均的容积扫描的黄斑 B 扫描(未平均图像)和后者的深度学习降噪版本(降噪图像)。我们通过评估所得图像的对比噪声比来评估潜在的信噪比提高,并测量多尺度结构相似性指数,以确定未平均和降噪图像在结构上是否与平均图像一致。我们评估了降噪对一种名为脉络膜血管指数的流行脉络膜血管密度指标的实际效果。
评估了 10 名年龄在 31 岁(24-64 岁)的受试者的 10 只眼睛。平均图像组和降噪图像组的深层脉络膜对比噪声比平均值相似(7.06 与 6.81,P=0.75),且两组的最大对比噪声比平均值均优于未平均组(14.75;P=0.001 和 P<0.001)。平均-降噪图像的平均多尺度结构相似性指数显著高于平均-未平均图像(0.85 与 0.61,P<0.001)。平均图像和降噪图像的脉络膜血管指数值相似(71.81 与 71.16,P=0.554)。
使用三种不同的指标,我们证明了深度学习降噪模型可以生成高质量的图像,这些图像可以模拟甚至超过高度平均扫描的质量。