School of Information and Communication Technology, University of Tasmania, TAS 7005, Australia.
Wicking Dementia Research and Education Centre, University of Tasmania, TAS 7000, Australia.
J Biomed Inform. 2022 Mar;127:104030. doi: 10.1016/j.jbi.2022.104030. Epub 2022 Feb 17.
BACKGROUND & OBJECTIVE: With populations aging, the number of people with dementia worldwide is expected to triple to 152 million by 2050. Seventy percent of cases are due to Alzheimer's disease (AD) pathology and there is a 10-20 year 'pre-clinical' period before significant cognitive decline occurs. We urgently need, cost effective, objective biomarkers to detect AD, and other dementias, at an early stage. Risk factor modification could prevent 40% of cases and drug trials would have greater chances of success if participants are recruited at an earlier stage. Currently, detection of dementia is largely by pen and paper cognitive tests but these are time consuming and insensitive to the pre-clinical phase. Specialist brain scans and body fluid biomarkers can detect the earliest stages of dementia but are too invasive or expensive for widespread use. With the advancement of technology, Artificial Intelligence (AI) shows promising results in assisting with detection of early-stage dementia. This scoping review aims to summarise the current capabilities of AI-aided digital biomarkers to aid in early detection of dementia, and also discusses potential future research directions.
METHODS & MATERIALS: In this scoping review, we used PubMed and IEEE Xplore to identify relevant papers. The resulting records were further filtered to retrieve articles published within five years and written in English. Duplicates were removed, titles and abstracts were screened and full texts were reviewed.
After an initial yield of 1,463 records, 1,444 records were screened after removal of duplication. A further 771 records were excluded after screening titles and abstracts, and 496 were excluded after full text review. The final yield was 177 studies. Records were grouped into different artificial intelligence based tests: (a) computerized cognitive tests (b) movement tests (c) speech, conversion, and language tests and (d) computer-assisted interpretation of brain scans.
In general, AI techniques enhance the performance of dementia screening tests because more features can be retrieved from a single test, there are less errors due to subjective judgements and AI shifts the automation of dementia screening to a higher level. Compared with traditional cognitive tests, AI-based computerized cognitive tests improve the discrimination sensitivity by around 4% and specificity by around 3%. In terms of speech, conversation and language tests, combining both acoustic features and linguistic features achieve the best result with accuracy around 94%. Deep learning techniques applied in brain scan analysis achieves around 92% accuracy. Movement tests and setting smart environments to capture daily life behaviours are two potential future directions that may help discriminate dementia from normal aging. AI-based smart environments and multi-modal tests are promising future directions to improve detection of dementia in the earliest stages.
随着人口老龄化,预计到 2050 年,全球痴呆症患者人数将增加两倍,达到 1.52 亿。70%的病例归因于阿尔茨海默病(AD)病理,在出现明显认知下降之前,有 10-20 年的“临床前”期。我们迫切需要具有成本效益的客观生物标志物,以便在早期阶段检测 AD 和其他痴呆症。如果在早期阶段招募参与者,那么改变风险因素可以预防 40%的病例,并且药物试验更有可能成功。目前,痴呆症的检测主要是通过纸笔认知测试,但这些测试耗时且对临床前阶段不敏感。专业的脑部扫描和体液生物标志物可以检测到痴呆症的最早阶段,但由于过于侵入性或昂贵,无法广泛使用。随着技术的进步,人工智能(AI)在辅助早期痴呆症检测方面显示出了有前景的结果。本范围综述旨在总结人工智能辅助数字生物标志物在早期检测痴呆症方面的现有能力,并讨论潜在的未来研究方向。
在这项范围综述中,我们使用 PubMed 和 IEEE Xplore 来确定相关论文。进一步筛选这些记录以检索在五年内发表并以英文书写的文章。去除重复项后,筛选标题和摘要,然后审查全文。
最初产生了 1463 条记录,去除重复项后,有 1444 条记录被筛选出来。在筛选标题和摘要后,又排除了 771 条记录,在审查全文后,又排除了 496 条记录。最终产量为 177 项研究。记录分为不同的基于人工智能的测试:(a)计算机认知测试,(b)运动测试,(c)言语、转换和语言测试,(d)计算机辅助脑扫描解释。
一般来说,人工智能技术提高了痴呆症筛查测试的性能,因为可以从单个测试中提取更多的特征,由于主观判断而导致的错误更少,并且人工智能将痴呆症筛查的自动化提升到了更高的水平。与传统认知测试相比,基于人工智能的计算机化认知测试可将区分敏感性提高约 4%,特异性提高约 3%。在言语、对话和语言测试方面,同时结合声学特征和语言特征,准确率可达 94%左右。应用于脑扫描分析的深度学习技术准确率约为 92%。运动测试和设置智能环境以捕捉日常生活行为是两个潜在的未来方向,可能有助于将痴呆症与正常衰老区分开来。基于人工智能的智能环境和多模态测试是改善早期痴呆症检测的有前途的未来方向。